Multi Player Poll!

[felsty]

Leaning toward option 2 just because there are more keepers in my side but I would be interested to see how people compare them in terms of point scoring..

What do you think?

[hawkers65]

This is how i see it:

1) Broughton (95) Sandilands (115) Varcoe (80) Knights (75) = 365
and
2) Grimes (95) Goldy (105) Johnson (100) Rookie (65) =365

So i can't split them. They only thing i have to split them is that option 1 has 4 players that will play week in week out where as option 2 has a fwd rookie and very few seem to have any sort of JS

[felsty]

thanks hawkers, its a tough one!

[quinny88]

Grimes safer than Broughton
Goldy should thrive as the stand alone ruck again where as Sandilands is a ticking time bomb
Johnson easily outscores varcoe
Knights ahead of a rookie but no garuntee on job security or his role within the team as yet.

option 2 far safer and high scoring imo

[kilbluff1985]

depends on rookie options

[Sabretooth Tigers]

Some of those rookie options could be  Staker, Macaffer, J Daniher, Tom Lee or even to throw in a smokey, Jed Lamb.
Should come up with at least 1 with a bit of JS. I went option 2 but not sold on either. Cheers.

[Nkimbaye Ntumbu]

Option 2, would lose a heap of sleep having Varcoe in my side.

[Adamant]

There's not much in it at all, but option 2 is definitely safer.

[Jay]

Would go option 2 pretty easily IMO

Much safer and still similar scoring potential

[big_cox21]

This is how i see it:

1) Broughton (95) Sandilands (115) Varcoe (80) Knights (75) = 365
and
2) Grimes (95) Goldy (105) Johnson (100) Rookie (65) =365

So i can't split them. They only thing i have to split them is that option 1 has 4 players that will play week in week out where as option 2 has a fwd rookie and very few seem to have any sort of JS

i would say broughten 90 varcoe 75 knights 70 = -15 from that prediction

also goldy 110 atleast. maybe even nearly 115 = +5 or 10.

so if you ask me thats a 20 or 25 point swing from what hawkers said. and everyone has said option 2 is safer too.

thats the option i would pick

[Swallow12]

This is how i see it:

1) Broughton (95) Sandilands (115) Varcoe (80) Knights (75) = 365
and
2) Grimes (95) Goldy (105) Johnson (100) Rookie (65) =365

So i can't split them. They only thing i have to split them is that option 1 has 4 players that will play week in week out where as option 2 has a fwd rookie and very few seem to have any sort of JS

i would say broughten 90 varcoe 75 knights 70 = -15 from that prediction

also goldy 110 atleast. maybe even nearly 115 = +5 or 10.

so if you ask me thats a 20 or 25 point swing from what hawkers said. and everyone has said option 2 is safer too.

thats the option i would pick

Agreed, as a North fan I'm surprised at the lack of love for Goldy, he loves being the sole ruck comfortable 110-115 avg IMO

[quinny88]

This is how i see it:

1) Broughton (95) Sandilands (115) Varcoe (80) Knights (75) = 365
and
2) Grimes (95) Goldy (105) Johnson (100) Rookie (65) =365

So i can't split them. They only thing i have to split them is that option 1 has 4 players that will play week in week out where as option 2 has a fwd rookie and very few seem to have any sort of JS

i would say broughten 90 varcoe 75 knights 70 = -15 from that prediction

also goldy 110 atleast. maybe even nearly 115 = +5 or 10.

so if you ask me thats a 20 or 25 point swing from what hawkers said. and everyone has said option 2 is safer too.

thats the option i would pick

Agreed, as a North fan I'm surprised at the lack of love for Goldy, he loves being the sole ruck comfortable 110-115 avg IMO

Lack of love for Goldy? He's been in most teams ive seen

[tor01doc]

2 by a greater margin than the poll results.