Which Team do you prefer?

[hawkers65]

Which Team do you prefer?

TEAM NAME: Supercoach Trial 1
DEF: B. Goddard, B. Gibbs, G. Broughton, J. Pittard, J. Thurlow, S. Docherty (D. Terlich, D. Van Unen)
MID: G. Ablett jnr, D. Swan, S. Pendlebury, J. Kennedy, T. Cotchin, D. Mundy, J. Lonergan, B. Crouch (J. O'Meara, J. Viney)
RUC: A. Sandilands, M. Leuenberger (S. Rowe, B. Grundy)
FWD: D. Cox, T. Rockliff, D. Martin, T. Varcoe, S. Byrnes, B. Macaffer (B. Staker, T. Lee)
CASH LEFT: $13,600

TEAM NAME: Supercoach Trial 2
DEF: B. Goddard, B. Gibbs, P. Hanley, J. Pittard, J. Thurlow, S. Docherty (D. Terlich, D. Van Unen)
MID: G. Ablett jnr, S. Pendlebury, J. Kennedy, T. Cotchin, D. Mundy, J. Lonergan, K. Mitchell, B. Crouch (J. O'Meara, J. Viney)
RUC: A. Sandilands, M. Leuenberger (S. Rowe, B. Grundy)
FWD: D. Cox, T. Rockliff, M. Wright, D. Martin, G. Broughton, S. Byrnes (B. Macaffer, B. Staker)
CASH LEFT: $7,300
(Will switch Broughts down back once a back rookie has maxed out. It may make my structure look weird but really its Broughton and Lee or Broughton and Thurlow. And the second IMO is much better)

Differences:

Team 1 --- Team 2 (My Opinion)
Broughton --- Hanley (95 --- 95)
Swan --- Mitchell (125 --- 75)
Varcoe --- Wright (70 --- 95)
Lee --- Broughton (60 --- 95)
(Total= 350 --- 360)

So what do think??

[Jroo]

I'd rather team 2. The upgrade you get from Wright and Broughton over Varcoe and Lee are defintley a lot better than the upgrade you get from Swan over Mitchell. Maybe add a poll to the thread as well.

[hawkers65]

Yeah thanks i added the poll and yeah i was leaning to that one too but i like the fact of having another uber premium in my side. Although I can't let myself miss out of Hanley and Wright as i know they'll both explode and i think Hanley can average 120 over the first 5 weeks of 2013 with his opponents. (Averaged 117 on them in 2012) Thanks for you input JROO!

[Jroo]

Yeah thanks i added the poll and yeah i was leaning to that one too but i like the fact of having another uber premium in my side. Although I can't let myself miss out of Hanley and Wright as i know they'll both explode and i think Hanley can average 120 over the first 5 weeks of 2013 with his opponents. (Averaged 117 on them in 2012) Thanks for you input JROO!

Really? Nice great stat there hawkers. I'm still not sure who to start Broughton or Hanley, might go Hanley as I'm a fan of him. I started him in my SC last year as a unique defender, than traded him out at like round 13 and than traded him back in at round 22 :o

[hawkers65]

Yeah thanks i added the poll and yeah i was leaning to that one too but i like the fact of having another uber premium in my side. Although I can't let myself miss out of Hanley and Wright as i know they'll both explode and i think Hanley can average 120 over the first 5 weeks of 2013 with his opponents. (Averaged 117 on them in 2012) Thanks for you input JROO!

Really? Nice great stat there hawkers. I'm still not sure who to start Broughton or Hanley, might go Hanley as I'm a fan of him. I started him in my SC last year as a unique defender, than traded him out at like round 13 and than traded him back in at round 22 :o

Plus he has been training predominantly with the Brisbane midfield group this preseason, so he'll still play mostly of halfback but should have those stints in the Midfield to bump up his scores 5-10 PPG
Whoops it was 116 but is still awesome! Yeah its a great stat! Here it is properly: (One of the few good stats i have come up with myself)

In the first 6 weeks of 2012 Hanley plays WB, Adel, GCS, NM, Melb and Sydney which he played 8 times in 2012 for an average of 116! He topped the 100 on 7 out of the 8 occasions with his lowest score (still above his 2012 average) of 92 and a highest score of a whopping 151!!! These where his scores:

WB: 117 and 151
Adel: 92
GCS: 109
NM: 112
Melb: 104 and 124
Syd: 119
Average 116

[Jroo]

Yeah thanks i added the poll and yeah i was leaning to that one too but i like the fact of having another uber premium in my side. Although I can't let myself miss out of Hanley and Wright as i know they'll both explode and i think Hanley can average 120 over the first 5 weeks of 2013 with his opponents. (Averaged 117 on them in 2012) Thanks for you input JROO!

Really? Nice great stat there hawkers. I'm still not sure who to start Broughton or Hanley, might go Hanley as I'm a fan of him. I started him in my SC last year as a unique defender, than traded him out at like round 13 and than traded him back in at round 22 :o

Whoops it was 116 but is still awesome! Yeah its a great stat! Here it is properly: (One of the few good stats i have come up with myself)

In the first 6 weeks of 2012 Hanley plays WB, Adel, GCS, NM, Melb and Sydney which he played 8 times in 2012 for an average of 116! He topped the 100 on 7 out of the 8 occasions with his lowest score (still above his 2012 average) of 92 and a highest score of a whopping 151!!! These where his scores:

WB: 117 and 151
Adel: 92
GCS: 109
NM: 112
Melb: 104 and 124
Syd: 119
Average 116

Cheers for that! Great state, looks like I'll be starting with Hanley again this year  8)

[hawkers65]

Yeah thanks i added the poll and yeah i was leaning to that one too but i like the fact of having another uber premium in my side. Although I can't let myself miss out of Hanley and Wright as i know they'll both explode and i think Hanley can average 120 over the first 5 weeks of 2013 with his opponents. (Averaged 117 on them in 2012) Thanks for you input JROO!

Really? Nice great stat there hawkers. I'm still not sure who to start Broughton or Hanley, might go Hanley as I'm a fan of him. I started him in my SC last year as a unique defender, than traded him out at like round 13 and than traded him back in at round 22 :o

Whoops it was 116 but is still awesome! Yeah its a great stat! Here it is properly: (One of the few good stats i have come up with myself)

In the first 6 weeks of 2012 Hanley plays WB, Adel, GCS, NM, Melb and Sydney which he played 8 times in 2012 for an average of 116! He topped the 100 on 7 out of the 8 occasions with his lowest score (still above his 2012 average) of 92 and a highest score of a whopping 151!!! These where his scores:

WB: 117 and 151
Adel: 92
GCS: 109
NM: 112
Melb: 104 and 124
Syd: 119
Average 116

Cheers for that! Great state, looks like I'll be starting with Hanley again this year  8)

Yeah jump on him! Plus he has been training predominately with the Brisbane Midfield group this preseason which should see him get some stints in the Midfield and bump up his score 5-10 PPG on top of his natural progression. So looks good for a 100 average.

[Jroo]

Yeah thanks i added the poll and yeah i was leaning to that one too but i like the fact of having another uber premium in my side. Although I can't let myself miss out of Hanley and Wright as i know they'll both explode and i think Hanley can average 120 over the first 5 weeks of 2013 with his opponents. (Averaged 117 on them in 2012) Thanks for you input JROO!

Really? Nice great stat there hawkers. I'm still not sure who to start Broughton or Hanley, might go Hanley as I'm a fan of him. I started him in my SC last year as a unique defender, than traded him out at like round 13 and than traded him back in at round 22 :o

Whoops it was 116 but is still awesome! Yeah its a great stat! Here it is properly: (One of the few good stats i have come up with myself)

In the first 6 weeks of 2012 Hanley plays WB, Adel, GCS, NM, Melb and Sydney which he played 8 times in 2012 for an average of 116! He topped the 100 on 7 out of the 8 occasions with his lowest score (still above his 2012 average) of 92 and a highest score of a whopping 151!!! These where his scores:

WB: 117 and 151
Adel: 92
GCS: 109
NM: 112
Melb: 104 and 124
Syd: 119
Average 116

Cheers for that! Great state, looks like I'll be starting with Hanley again this year  8)

Yeah jump on him! Plus he has been training predominately with the Brisbane Midfield group this preseason which should see him get some stints in the Midfield and bump up his score 5-10 PPG on top of his natural progression. So looks good for a 100 average.

Yeah, should get more midfield time in 2013. I reckon he'll be running off a wing. Hopefully he gets to 100  :)