Stevie J vs Cyril vs (fully fit) Daisy vs Jimmy

Started by cortez, January 06, 2013, 10:19:42 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

which one of the 4 stars would you pick in your forward line?

S. Johnson
C. Rioli
D. Thomas
J. Bartel

brownmans muffins

Not sure Jimmy has it in him anymore, as much as I love him.
Not a big Daisy fan - can't see him being a 'must have' at the business end of season - clearly down the Magpies pecking order.

Stevie J and Cyril are both interesting.
End of season you'd ideally have both in, it's just which one if any to start with.
Stevie is more prone to drop a 20-30 score on and deliver a big price drop so maybe wait for his inevitable stinker.
Cyril on the other hand is a bit more of an injury risk and may not be as much of a 'mid' as SJ.

Coin toss for mine.

DanA

Harsh on Bartel. He played the back half of the season with a fractured foot which significantly reduced his time in the middle but he still managed to score consistently. The year before he had the problem with his elbow. I think people are mistaking injury with a declining output due to age.