Rate, opinions & suggestions for Team Bannars

Started by Bannars100, March 05, 2013, 11:58:31 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Bannars100

I'm a pom who has got addicted to AFL i have been here a few years and done my research i would say i'm an intermediate need some opinions or suggestions if i'm there and heading in the right direction or going the wrong way and needs tweaking.

Backs - Goddard, Gibbs, H Shaw, N Vlastuin, B Goodes, S Docherty (Subs - Stevenson, Colquhoun)
Mids - Swan (c), Ablett (v), Pendlebury, Armitage, Moloney, Whitfield, Wines, K Mitchell (Subs - O'Meara, Blicavs)
Ruck - McEvoy, Jacobs (Subs - Daw, Naismith)
Forwards - Franklin, Bartel, Rockliff, Robinson, LeCras, Mayes (Subs - Neade, Paparone)

Cash left- 4k

Money

Nice but there could be some things done differently-

Suggestions-
McEvoy/Jacobs- Leuenberger
With remaining cash upgrade- Armitage or Moloney to a Premo
Armitage at M4 too risky, at M5 could work
Mayes- Macaffer

Bannars100


Toga

Decent looking team mate! My thoughts:

Backs: Good looking line but I prefer Hartlett to Shaw, see more upside in him and reckon he can go 90+ this year 8) Rookies are good for this line!

Midfielders: Agree with Money here, think that it is a bit risky having only three premiums in this line. Rookies are all good but I would probably go with Viney over Blicavs, but if he's named round 1 go for it if you think he presents value!

Rucks: As Money said, would downgrade Jacobs to Leuenberger - Jacobs, while a fantastic ruckman, doesn't do enough around the ground in the way of possessions and goals etc to be a fantastic fantasy selection. Downgrading him to the cheap and value-presenting Leuenberger will give you enough to upgrade Moloney to a premium midfielder.

Forwards: Another very solid line. I like your selection in LeCras - became unpopular due to his inflated price-tag, but I think he still presents awesome value. Wouldn't really change anything here, but would have a look at Brent Macaffer instead of Sam Mayes (if Mayes isn't named round 1). Macaffer should be in the Pies' best 22, and I expect him to average around 60-70, which for 130K presents good value.

Suggestions: Pretty well rounded team mate, my suggestion would be the same as Money's:
1. Jacobs -> Leuenberger
2. Moloney/Armitage -> Beams/Cotchin/Redden/Murphy/other