Main Menu

Liam Jurrah

Started by quinny88, October 14, 2012, 11:29:19 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Anyone considering Jurrrah if Port draft him?

No way
4 (44.4%)
Maybe
4 (44.4%)
Lock
1 (11.1%)

Total Members Voted: 1

quinny88

I Didnt bother making a player profile just yet as he isnt on an AFL list at this point, but after Ken Hinkley has admitted Ports interest in him, if they were to draft him would he come into consideration for your SC team?

Fan planner has him at $182,700 as a fwd that could potentially average between 70-80.

Has a court case some time in March, but if he was to come out of that okay would he be considered?

Mailman the 2nd

He'd have to be a bit cheaper to consider risking it on him.

quinny88

Yeah I was just thinking if Port did pick him up he would be a rookie listed player which would make him cheaper wouldnt it? Not exactly sure how it works

Adamant

No way at that price...mabye if rookie priced.

quinny88

Quote from: Adamant on October 14, 2012, 11:39:17 PM
No way at that price...mabye if rookie priced.

Port said that if they did pick Jurrah up it would be on the rookie list. Unfortuantely he played one game this year though for a score of 40 something so he doesnt get the full 50% discount from not playing at all.

Do you know what price all this would have him around?

tbagrocks

I'm not sure on Port Adelaide forwards yet, except Gray (but he can't stay fit anyway) I just don't see them getting enough ball and not forward yet anyway, a year or two when, Redden, Ebert, Broadbent, Hartlett, Boak, Wingard all start to gel as a unit, then I will get on a Jurrah or Butcher, even Schultz

Kellogscrunchynut

Not convinced on him as a player, and off the field he seems to have issues.

m1tch robo

he will average 50 at the most. Horribly inconsistent. That's if he even gets a gig somewhere

quinny88

Quote from: m1tch robo on October 15, 2012, 05:02:12 PM
he will average 50 at the most. Horribly inconsistent. That's if he even gets a gig somewhere

Averaged 73, 71 and 70 in his first 3 seasons so not sure why he would drop to 50 at most if he's given the opportunity to play?
The problem is going to be weather he gets picked up and if he ends up locked up

Hagebear

No way. Would much prefer a quality rookie and not be nervous about wether he'll lose the plot again.

Jroo

Quote from: Adamant on October 14, 2012, 11:39:17 PM
No way at that price...mabye if rookie priced.
+1 if he was a bit cheaper than he would be worth looking at, if not then PASS

fidou

Whoever voted Lock it may be prudent to wait until the court case is over before he may go inside, or a slap on the wrist. Which may even have a guilty verdict. Which will then become a slippery slope purely because what will his new club do? Nothing because his indiscretion was with a previous club or will they be in the same conundrum as Carlton with Scotland? Whichever way it wont be an answer until most probably late March 2013. But if everything comes clean etc and he's available Round 1 its not a bad choice at 180K and if you need someone to fill in the forwards. So in a nutshell there is a lot of hoops to get through before he becomes F7.

Shihan7

Would much rather a rook and save the extra cash.

Speculator

Not for me. This machete business is a big turn off. Who knows when he may go missing again?