Which ruck and why?

Started by ubeaut, August 31, 2012, 03:11:14 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Please choose a ruck and comment

Maric vs Port
5 (33.3%)
Jacobs vs GC
3 (20%)
Sandilands vs Dees
7 (46.7%)
Goldstein vs GWS
0 (0%)
Other (please specify)
0 (0%)

Total Members Voted: 0

ubeaut

Sandi has Griffen in the team. I've read toe injury rumours on another site. Clarke is emergency. I can't trust Lyin'.

Jacobs seems to be a bit off but surely should smash Dixon from GC. No other ruckman listed to play besides Tippett. Can kick goals if forward particularly vs GC.

Maric has been great for most of the year. Can also kick goals vs Port.

Goldstein got smashed last week. Can he bounce back?

For the record I'm trading Giles. And I have Cox.

Brad1976

I Would go Maric over Sandilands because of injury rumors. I am going to trade Giles as well but I only have 530k so I think I wil get Mcevoy.

ubeaut

Cheers Brad. Please leave comments people. They are much appreciated.

Adamant

Maric for me.
Most consistent option and should smash Redden in the ruck.

ubeaut

Cheers Adamant. C'mon people 5 votes? How hard is it to click the mouse button? :D

ubeaut


colmullet

Sandi should bump out 120+ pretty easily you would think

Spinking

Personally I'd go Jacobs v GC.  Probably a fair chance to get 40+ hitouts and will dominate around the ground.

ubeaut

Quote from: colmullet on August 31, 2012, 04:53:32 PM
Sandi should bump out 120+ pretty easily you would think

Yes u would think that. Was going to just get him last round and imagine my annoyance when he got 157 while Giles got 79. But I've heard too many toe injury rumours. Clarke is an emergency and Griffen is in the team already.

Tossing up between Jacobs and Maric.

Cheers for tha replies people.

MLS

Sandilands has the highest ceiling, I'd be locking him in

ubeaut

Quote from: MLS on August 31, 2012, 06:49:28 PM
Sandilands has the highest ceiling, I'd be locking him in
What if he doesn't play? Even if I could afford to name a ruck emergency it would be Campbell who has scored 25 before. And I'd rather a Mid/Fwd/Back emergency.

jamesalex

Sandi's a doubt for tommorow isn't he? Go maric.

Spuds11

sandi everyday of the week but the day he has an injury cloud maric is your boy