Who would you play? (quick poll)

[DT-SC]

Gibsons form is undeniable, 113.3 in his last 3, 112.0 in his last 5, up again freo
Rockliffs form is undeniably bad, 76.3 in his last 3, 82.4 in his last 5
However, against bottom poor teams (WB, GC, GWS, MELB)  he's got 6 tons in 6 games, averaging 126.5
hasn't played PA this year but scored 121 on them last year
i think Rocky, as much as he's let me down he could be worth the punt??

WHO WOULD YOU FIELD?

[Dudge]

You normally say Gibbo on current form, but North v Freo is a bit of a worry. On the other hand Rocky v Port, who knows what he might dish up, he COULD kick half a dozen. This ones a go with ya gut

[Adamant]

I've had Rocky from the start and although he has been shocking...he still has the potential to knock out 140+ and against Port - Im thinking he's due.

[DT Sainter]

who would of thought at the start of this year you'd be sitting here in the prelim final deciding between rocky and a rookie. i think rockys potential is increased cos he does well against bottom teams and they are playing port, but named forward and been playing forward a lot...im just not sure you can overlook an in form gibson who is guranteed midfield/wing time moreso then rocky...id be leaning towards gibbo

[LaHug]

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,66531.0.html