The old chestnut is back

Started by Blues Blues Blues, August 21, 2012, 04:56:36 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Lake v S Shaw- who starts?

Lake (v Cats at SS)
2 (14.3%)
Shaw (v Dees at MCG)
12 (85.7%)

Total Members Voted: 1

Blues Blues Blues

Lake's 54 and S Shaw's 113 is the reason for the re-emergence of this question.

Anyone else facing same dilemma?

kilbluff1985

Shaw for me

Lake will get one of Geelongs KPP

grange76

Lake will get Pods in all likelyliness but the ball is going to be down that end A LOT so lots of Mark from opposition and rebound 50 ( If he is good enough) i hope so because i have the same dilema and I think I will put him on the field.

Shaw more likely to have more possessions normally, rebounding out of defence but i can't see them having many inside 50's unless Griffen has a game like last week. Lots of other players to take points from Shaw. Dog's are cooked for the season. Cats on fire. 

Lake for me

Elite87

Sam Shaw.. no doubt about it.. Lake has just been lazy and isnt as efficient with his disposal as he used to be.. watching the game on the weekend, alot of sideways kicking where he could have booted it into the 50..  plus Shaw is playing like a keen rookie,  should do well with Crows' nice run home...

Danstar

I've just been putting the player with the highest average on the field first. has worked quite well the last few weeks. bar last week of Chapman