Whos the weak link and who should i replace him with?

Started by smirks, August 21, 2012, 01:49:55 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

smirks

Greeny's Smurfs

Round Score: 2,277

DEF: B Deledio (78), H Scotland (57), J Grimes (125), B Goddard (125), G Birchall (84), J Adcock (86), A Carrazzo (48), C Delaney (0), P Yagmoor (0)

MID: G Ablett (175), J Watson (98), M Boyd (100), S Thompson (108), J Selwood (67), S Pendlebury (97), E Yeo (38), T McIntyre (0)

RUCK: D Cox (99), J Giles (115), J Redden (0), O Stephenson (0)

FWD: D Beams (129), S Sidebottom (122), P Dangerfield (108), S Johnson (98), J Roughead (128), L Franklin (0), D Zorko (87), A Hall (0), G Weedon (0)

$29,700

all feedback is appreciated :)

kilbluff1985

how many trades you got? don't really think there is much weakness really looks solid

Dudge

Very nice team, but i would hold trades for injuries, resting late outs, as your bench looks a bit thin

fertalong


Slap

Adcock or Giles.

Sure Giles has been good the last few weeks.. but taking a gamble on him could sell you short.  His form prior to the last few weeks could be costly.

Adcock - for the same reason as Giles.  Consistency is key.  If you can minimise risks by picking consistent scorers, I'd do it.  But the only problem is, you seem to have them all in your backline anyway.

Giles for mine OR trade to cover a doughnut/injury/retirement/etc because your bench cover is very thin/lacks a decent scoring ceiling.