Which 3?

[m1tch robo]

I have 4 trades left


With chapman in doubt I can go him to stevie J and Sam Gibson to Beams which yields option 1 players on my field and leaves 2 trades remaining for next 2 weeks.

Or I can go Hargrave to Birchall and that leaves option 2 players on my field with 3 trades remaining for next 2 weeks.

If you think they'll score similar vote option 3.

At the moment I'm liking the 3 trades going into next week - should be a big advantage.

[Adamant]

Stevie J, Beams & Ellis quite easily IMO.

[Mr.Craig]

I'm extremely fearful that Birch will be rested and even if he isn't the ball might not be in the Hawks backline too often. So if you're keen to upgrade Hargrave I'd look elsewhere.

If you were to trade Chapman for Beams and play Gibson in the mids how much money would that leave you for a backman upgrade?

[m1tch robo]

I'm extremely fearful that Birch will be rested and even if he isn't the ball might not be in the Hawks backline too often. So if you're keen to upgrade Hargrave I'd look elsewhere.

If you were to trade Chapman for Beams and play Gibson in the mids how much money would that leave you for a backman upgrade?

$4,000 haha but I like your thinking. However you'd still think that birchall will outscore Ellis by around 30-40 points

[Spinking]

Birchall had a great week, but he has gone missing on a few occasions this season. 

I reckon SJ, Beams, Ellis is the way to go, primarily because of Beams.  Absolute jet and seems to thrive with Swanny out of the team.

[Mr.Craig]

I guess I'll go with Option 1 then. You'd have to back in the two premiums/one rookie vs two rookies/one premium. Gibson might be a little quieter against Collingwood and you can't bank on Smith continuing his good form.

[m1tch robo]

I'm hoping chapman is in because in that case I can go Treloar to SJ and Hargrave to Birchall which will mean I'm starting Chapman SJ and Birchall with gibson and dev smith as emergencies then next week I'll use 2 trades to put beams into my fwd line.

[Windigo]

Yeah, option one.

Chappy's injury might drag on more than you expect.  :-\

[Barra17]

How bout chappy to beams, hargrave to grimes?

[kilbluff1985]

option one

even if Chappy gets named he might be a late out or wear a vest at some stage