whats the beta trade ???

[buzza]

whats the better trade- giles to cox or ellis to a prem defender ?

[KoopKicka]

Ellis to a premium defender.

[rowshow]

not sure about the beta trade but the alpha trade is giles>cox

[fertalong]

You gain a lot more going Ellis to Premo.

[rowshow]

giles is good for 65-70 from here on. cox around the 100-105 with a much higher ceiling of 140odd thats about a 35-40 pt gain minimum

ellis will score about 60 odd meaning a defender premo will need to score about 95 to justify at the barest minumum and given its the end of the season and any decent coach already has all the obvious defender premos i see the giles trade safer and just as good. In saying that if you dont have 1 of the must haves like carazzo deledio etc then obviously one of them. But i presume everyones backline is very similair

[kilbluff1985]

yeah really need to see which defenders you got

[Adamant]

I would go Ellis > Premo