Swan and Franklin to whom?

Started by Dommie, August 10, 2012, 06:44:47 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Dommie

2 trades left...

Finished 5th and 6th in my two main leagues...

Cover for both the boys (Gibson and Cloke) but if i lose without trading i will be devastated!

My team-
Goddard Deledio Birchall Heppell Lake Carrazzo H Shaw  (S Shaw & Darley)

Swan Ablett Thompson Selwood Pendles Rockliff  (Gibson and Sexton)

Jacobs Nic Nat  (Redden & Campbell)

Dangerfield  Sidebottom Johnson Lewis Zorko Goodes Cloke  (Franklin & Couch)


Always planned on upgrading Lake at some stage but this week calls for drastic measures. Was thinking Swan to Watson and Franklin to Beams, pretty straight foward sideways swap but just wondering if there is a better option out there?

Kellogscrunchynut

Hold Swan and you've named Zorko twice.

LaHug

Honestly, I'd go Franklin to Beams but hold Swan. No point trading Swan because you'll want him back if you want a chance at the grand final.

Chelskiman

Watson and Beams look very solid to me if you're ready to pull the trigger.  If I were you I'd personally hold Swan at the very least.  Beams is in ripping form though, so you can't really go wrong with him, especially seeing as nobody knows what is going on with Buddy.

Plastic Boy

Beams will get the Sydney tag and I'd expect a reduced score.  Looking at your team I'd trade Swan to fill that mid spot but leave your FWD's

Dommie

Cheers for the input people! :)

I'm probably gonna keep The Lord Swan on the bench and hope for some continuing Gibson magic, bring Fyfe back into my team after his long exodus for Franklin and turn ex DT icon Lake into current DT icon Waters...

Bring it on!!!

Windigo

Swanny really isn't worth a trade.

Many people will be taking Gibbo's score this week.

Bak2Form

Quote from: Chelskiman on August 10, 2012, 06:47:48 PM
Watson and Beams look very solid to me if you're ready to pull the trigger.  If I were you I'd personally hold Swan at the very least.  Beams is in ripping form though, so you can't really go wrong with him, especially seeing as nobody knows what is going on with Buddy.
+1