Would you field the proven gun or the in form youngster?

[JamSainter]

So it is a bit early for this and a bit weird even contemplating it buttt....
Adam Goodes (vs Collingwood) = doesn't have a particularly good record against the Pies
on the other hand...
Adam Treloar is in fine form and comes up against fellow cellar dwellers Gold Coast this weekend. Earlier in the year he scored a good 96 against the Suns.
So who do you field?!?!

[KoopKicka]

A tough one, I reckon Treloar, but dont blame me if it backfires. :p

[JamSainter]

Oh no - I won't  ;) thanks Koop,
But am slightly concerned about his 2 or 3 really showerty scores during the year to date but hopefully he can turn it on and score 120 and it would be a masterstroke!
surely I aint the only person in this position!?

[KoopKicka]

Oh no - I won't  ;) thanks Koop,
But am slightly concerned about his 2 or 3 really showerty scores during the year to date but hopefully he can turn it on and score 120 and it would be a masterstroke!
surely I aint the only person in this position!?

I wouldnt think so :)

He scored 96 last time verse the Suns, theres no reason why he shouldnt do it again. :)

[Torpedo10]

Mate, Goodesy shouldn't let you down. Big match, crucial match, He loves those.  ;)

[yorgis]

with bolton out who knows? maybe he'll get a run in the mids

[tkringle]

I'm thinking similar but its Cloke I might bench for Treloar!

[kilbluff1985]

Goodes = Safer option

[Nieso FC]

You have Goodsey in your team as a Premium for a reason....always back your Premium!

[JamSainter]

You have Goodsey in your team as a Premium for a reason....always back your Premium!

Thanks - I am backing him for the remainder of the season but he seems to under perform against the Pies (like the whole Sydney do I guess) - Well I will back in Goodes for now!