Waters or Scotland

[Shihan7]

Who should I get to finish off my backline?
My defenders are: Goddard, Lids, Birchall, Grimes, Suckling, Conca, ? (S.Shaw, Clarke)
I've got an elimination final this week so need to strengthen my defense..
Cheers

[Jukes]

Scotland, eagles have a hard run home which should see them drop to 7th or 8th spot on the ladder (Geelong, Hawthorn and Collingwood plus Port) meaning Waters' scoring should suffer, as do most when their team gets stuffed.

[Adamant]

Waters for ceiling, Scotland for consistent 90+ and durability....I would probs go Scotland.

[HolyGrail_2010]

Waters for ceiling, Scotland for consistent 90+ and durability....I would probs go Scotland.

+1

Scotland if you wanna play it safe, but go a Waters if you wanna take a risk.

[mwaxo]

I would actually say Waters.

Tough teams can often mean a backman like him has a bigger workload. Plus he still scores well against good opposition, and in my opinion the Eagles have more to play for than Carlton. Eagles want a top four spot, and I think Carlton know they aren't going to play finals.