Dev smith or Treloar out for Beams

[m1tch robo]

Lookin for some advice, both these GWS rookies are in good form. They've served me well whilst buddy and robbo have been out. When my team is all available one of them must play as F7 if I don't trade. I'm wondering if I should trade one to beams this week and if so which one. Currently leaning towards offing devon coz I think Treloar has better scoring potential.

4 trades left and cut throat finals this week. I need to do a downgrade too to complete the trade. To make the decision harder they are playing gold coast this week so could easily both ton up.

feedback appreciated

[Adamant]

With 4 trades left...I would definitely get rid of one of them.

Treloar - 2012
Average: 76.9
70+ Scores: 9
Sub-50 Scores: 2
Low Scores: 17, 39, 57


Smith - 2012
Average: 68.7
70+ Scores: 9
Sub-50 Scores: 4 (1 sub-affected)
Low Scores: 37, 39, 44

Devon gets the chop for me.

[aces-high]

Yep as adament said oust devon. He has been a loyal servant but treloar is a better scorer and is a better option for bench cover. Getting in beams for the finals is a must! So the logical decision is to keep the in form treloar who is playing on the ball atm and oust devon the little terrior :)

[Windigo]

Treloar looks solid & Dev has really hit some form recently, but I'd lean toward chopping Dev also. ;)