Ask Q (3/8/12)

[Master Q]

Last two trades and $71,000 in the bank.
A loss this week could have me out of the 8 (shocking luck), anyway should I make moves to clear the money that is sitting on my bench and who should I get that will smash it this week and remain hot for finals?

Team: (trade thoughts in bold)
Backs: Deledio, Scotland, Suckling, Goddard, Adcock, Carrazzo, Smedts (Broughton, Shaw)
Mids: Swan, Boyd, Ablett, Mitchell, Selwood, Pendlebury (Gibson, Miles)
Rucks: Cox, Maric (Redden, Campbell)
Forwards: Sidebottom, Dangerfield, Chapman, Porplyzia, Zorko, Goodes, Murdoch (Franklin, Tomlinson)

My Opponent: (uniques in bold)
Backs: Deledio, Goddard, Waters, Adcock, Carrazzo, Morris, Yarran (Shaw, Baguley)
Mids: Swan, Boyd, Watson, Ablett, Mitchell, Pendlebury (Gibson, Robinson)
Rucks: Jacobs, Griffin (Redden, Campbell)
Forwards: Beams, Sidebottom, Martin, Cloke, Porplyzia, Zorko, Goodes (Franklin, Treloar)

I'd be looking to offload Broughton for someone like Birchall, Heath Shaw etc.

PS: Don't be afraid to cheer!

[The It]

Who to play out of Stephenson and Campbell?

[Master Q]

Basic simple question who to start?

Jenkins or Campbell ?

Tough, but I think Big O.

[LaHug]

I have done maths, fears of injury, prices, personal opinions, etc. etc. and can't split these 3 trade options...

$45,400 in the bank, 4 trades remaining

1) This week: Broughton to Bell, Stanton to Boyd. Then: Ellis to Scotland/Waters. Leaves me with approx. $1500.
Pros: Gets Boyd now and leaves another week to choose between Scotland and Waters, don't have to field Gibson this week. Cons: Boyd's BE is 169, leaves me with less cash, have to field Ellis or Spurr this week.

2) This week: Broughton to Bell, Ellis to Scotland. Then: Stanton to Boyd. Leaves me with approx. $26.5k
Pros: Don't have to field Ellis/Spurr this week, nets the most cash. Cons: Scotland plays Sydney this week, have to field Gibson.

3) This week: Broughton to Bell, Ellis to Waters. Then: Stanton to Boyd. Leaves me with approx. $20.5k
Pros: Don't have to field Ellis/Spurr this week, Waters likely to ton up in Derby. Cons: Waters is injury/suspension prone, have to field Gibson.

Can't split them. Help?

Yep! Is hard to split them! I'd be looking at 2 or 3 as Stanton is still a chance to score...

Probably will be trading Stanton next week (if not this week) no matter what. I have the cash to turn him into Boyd and I'd like to do that before he bleeds cash to the point of no return...

[Master Q]

Option A: Milera to Goodes / Robbo to Dangerfield / Keep Franklin

Option B: Milera to fyfe / Franklin to Pavlich / Keep Robbo

Current forward

Beams / Sidey / Johnson / Whitecross / Zorko / Franklin / Robbo / [milera] / [crozier]

So goodes / fyfe will be cover as both my cover got dropped / injured

Or any other forwards. Can no afford ROK. But how about chapman? figured Pav / Danger since they have easy run home

Easily A. Should loo at Pav, Danger and Chappy - not sure why you wouldn't take one of these guys over Goodes.

[Master Q]

will you accept my challenge???

Look at the thread bud!

Which trade should i do ellis - suckling or ward/barlow/kennedy (which one) - murphy

Ellis -> Suckling.

Who to play out of Stephenson and Campbell?

Big O - Just.

[Master Q]

I have done maths, fears of injury, prices, personal opinions, etc. etc. and can't split these 3 trade options...

$45,400 in the bank, 4 trades remaining

1) This week: Broughton to Bell, Stanton to Boyd. Then: Ellis to Scotland/Waters. Leaves me with approx. $1500.
Pros: Gets Boyd now and leaves another week to choose between Scotland and Waters, don't have to field Gibson this week. Cons: Boyd's BE is 169, leaves me with less cash, have to field Ellis or Spurr this week.

2) This week: Broughton to Bell, Ellis to Scotland. Then: Stanton to Boyd. Leaves me with approx. $26.5k
Pros: Don't have to field Ellis/Spurr this week, nets the most cash. Cons: Scotland plays Sydney this week, have to field Gibson.

3) This week: Broughton to Bell, Ellis to Waters. Then: Stanton to Boyd. Leaves me with approx. $20.5k
Pros: Don't have to field Ellis/Spurr this week, Waters likely to ton up in Derby. Cons: Waters is injury/suspension prone, have to field Gibson.

Can't split them. Help?

Yep! Is hard to split them! I'd be looking at 2 or 3 as Stanton is still a chance to score...

Probably will be trading Stanton next week (if not this week) no matter what. I have the cash to turn him into Boyd and I'd like to do that before he bleeds cash to the point of no return...

Well you just told me what YOU want to do. I told you what I'd do. Trade him next week?

Gibson > Ellis/Spurr

[LaHug]

I have done maths, fears of injury, prices, personal opinions, etc. etc. and can't split these 3 trade options...

$45,400 in the bank, 4 trades remaining

1) This week: Broughton to Bell, Stanton to Boyd. Then: Ellis to Scotland/Waters. Leaves me with approx. $1500.
Pros: Gets Boyd now and leaves another week to choose between Scotland and Waters, don't have to field Gibson this week. Cons: Boyd's BE is 169, leaves me with less cash, have to field Ellis or Spurr this week.

2) This week: Broughton to Bell, Ellis to Scotland. Then: Stanton to Boyd. Leaves me with approx. $26.5k
Pros: Don't have to field Ellis/Spurr this week, nets the most cash. Cons: Scotland plays Sydney this week, have to field Gibson.

3) This week: Broughton to Bell, Ellis to Waters. Then: Stanton to Boyd. Leaves me with approx. $20.5k
Pros: Don't have to field Ellis/Spurr this week, Waters likely to ton up in Derby. Cons: Waters is injury/suspension prone, have to field Gibson.

Can't split them. Help?

Yep! Is hard to split them! I'd be looking at 2 or 3 as Stanton is still a chance to score...

Probably will be trading Stanton next week (if not this week) no matter what. I have the cash to turn him into Boyd and I'd like to do that before he bleeds cash to the point of no return...

Well you just told me what YOU want to do. I told you what I'd do. Trade him next week?

Gibson > Ellis/Spurr

The "then" was for next week. Thanks :)

[Tominator]

Sam Shaw or Mark Baguley to start ?

And also, which 3 do I start out of Zorko, Porplyzia, Goodes and Treloar?

Thanks again Q!!

[miegs3]

Last two trades and $71,000 in the bank.
A loss this week could have me out of the 8 (shocking luck), anyway should I make moves to clear the money that is sitting on my bench and who should I get that will smash it this week and remain hot for finals?

Team: (trade thoughts in bold)
Backs: Deledio, Scotland, Suckling, Goddard, Adcock, Carrazzo, Smedts (Broughton, Shaw)
Mids: Swan, Boyd, Ablett, Mitchell, Selwood, Pendlebury (Gibson, Miles)
Rucks: Cox, Maric (Redden, Campbell)
Forwards: Sidebottom, Dangerfield, Chapman, Porplyzia, Zorko, Goodes, Murdoch (Franklin, Tomlinson)

My Opponent: (uniques in bold)
Backs: Deledio, Goddard, Waters, Adcock, Carrazzo, Morris, Yarran (Shaw, Baguley)
Mids: Swan, Boyd, Watson, Ablett, Mitchell, Pendlebury (Gibson, Robinson)
Rucks: Jacobs, Griffin (Redden, Campbell)
Forwards: Beams, Sidebottom, Martin, Cloke, Porplyzia, Zorko, Goodes (Franklin, Treloar)

I'd be looking to offload Broughton for someone like Birchall, Heath Shaw etc.

PS: Don't be afraid to cheer!

Never afraid to cheer, thanks for initial reply.

So do you think it's better to go Broughton -> Birchall/Shaw running with Smedts on the field in the forward line?
I was probably leaning towards Franklin -> Beams, Broughton -> Johnson or someone ($373,500)
or Franklin -> ? ($467,300), Broughton -> Waters

[Master Q]

---

That's it for this week! Good luck!

PS: Don't be afraid to cheer or help me out here - http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,65982.0.html

If I didn't answer your question PM me. I am a busy man and it is past the deadline - make sure to ask me earlier next time  ::)