Scotland+176k or Fisher+317k+ maybe save a trade

[Madmax75]

Decision time this week.

If I want Fisher then its this week with his be of 38. He is also a bargain and allows me to hopefully save a trade in a couple of weeks when I do Gibson--Fyfe or another m/f. Fisher could maybe pull out a rubbish score of 50-60 a lot more likely than Scotland.
Scotland lowish be of 71 great consistency but about 140 k more than Fisher which is a lot of money with trades getting low. But Scotland could get me over the line in the finals next week.

This is doing my head in. Any thoughts most appreciated.

[Danstar]

You want to field the strongest possible team you can. Depending on your other Defenders, if you think you have enough class in there and Fisher being your D6 or D7 get him.

If he is anything lower then that, get Scotland

[Blues Blues Blues]

Depends on your team and trade situation, but I would be inclined to go Scotland. Much more consistent

[Madmax75]

Two very good points, thanks for that. My Team is:

B Goddard Deledio Waters Broughton Lake Grimes Spurr (Ellis S Shaw )
C Gabj Thompson Watson Priddis Selwood Pendles (McDonald Gibson)
R Cox Kreuzer (Giles Big o)
F  Franklin Beams Sidebottom Danger Zorko Martin Cloke  (Dickson Couch )

So yep to get the best team Scotland this week for Broughton as his be is about 71 and then Carrazzo next week for Spurr. Gives me 5 defenders averaging 100 or more with Lake Grimes. Plan would b then to try and win the first final (I'm safe in top 4, 6 trades, 306 k) as then I would have 4 trades for hopefully last two finals-one downgrade one upgrade each final or sideways if say Thompson etc get rested.