Who to keep Ellis/Spurr or S Shaw?

[Madmax75]

Broughton out this week for Scotland then...who has the best js? I think Ellis S Shaw Spurr. Scoring potential ? S Shaw Spurr Ellis in that order. What do you think ?

[Danstar]

Same question for me. Not sure who to field. Spurr - Ellis or Shaw


Spurr against WCE might be tough for a rookie.

Ellis against brisbane over there, 50/50 on his scoring potential

Shaw against a Down and out Essendon, coming off a 2 week break is also a 50/50 for me.

I think I'm gonna go with Shaw on the field.

Based on he has the highest average

[roo boys!]

I think Shaw has the best scoring potential (answering your question Danstar) and he should have quite good JS as well. The last two weeks were injury based, not dropping.

[The Bomber]

Ellis and Shaw have equally high JS. Both have played every opportunity they have got only missing to injury (Shaw) or not missing a game this season (Ellis). Only because Ellis has played every game this season is why I say he has the best JS

JS:
Ellis > Shaw > Spurr

Scoring potential, Ellis and Shaw have been more consistent over a longer period of time. SPurr has only played well a couple of recent weeks.
Therefore Shaw > Ellis > Spurr

Trade out Spurr...

[Madmax75]

Thanks for the reply. Yep prob b a few teams having to make your call. Looks like the poll says keep Shaw . Spurr and Broughton look like they r out this week or next for Scotland and  ? An extra downgrade to bell this week and I get carrots or 2 trades with fisher in too this week?