Goodes v Porps, Which defender

Started by erry, July 30, 2012, 05:20:49 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

erry

Hi guys,

I've got 2 questions:
1. Which do I play, Goodes, who has been very average as of late and doesn't really play in the midfield anymore but is a proven performer or Porps, who has been great lately, more consistent lately and grabbed a couple of tons?

2. I've got about 424 000 to spend on a defender to complete my team, who should i get? I'm leaning towards Suckling but I'm not completely sold

Cheers

Capper

What defenders do you currently have???
for 424000 you can get Birchall, Heater, MJ, McPharlin, Corey, Goddard, Heppell

Go with Goodes as Tex might get some of Porps ball from now on

erry

Sorry my defence is currently:
Goddard, Birchall, Heppell, Deledio, Scotland, Carrazzo, Ellis and then Spurr and S. Shaw

aces-high

Get heater and stick with goodesy man :) Eliminate a 47 he scored against the blues and hes 4 other previous scores have been 91,97, 118 and 116 so he doesnt mind playing them and should bounce back from this sly form slump!

Spinking

I'd look at Grimes for your backline.  Been playing well lately and spending more time in the mids.

I would lean towards Goodes for your forward line, but keep an eye on how he trains this week.  Copped a corkie in the last quarter last week, should be fine, but worth watching how he comes up.