zomg Finalised Team. Find the hole/s?

hespey · August 03, 2012, 04:36:14 PM

I've used all my trades up this week (out LAKE, J.RIEWOLDT, in WATERS, FYFE).

I realise that this is silly, being that finals haven't even started, but lake and riewoldt were my lowest performing fwd and def, and they were both about to plummet in price, and waters and fyfe are about to skyrocket (or so I hope).

This is my final team. I'm top 4 in all 5 leagues. The leagues are relatively competitive, but not really on the superstar level. How do you think this team will stand up for the rest of the year? Should I be reversing my final two upgrades???????

Cheers for any advice!

Deledio, Scotland, Goddard, Birchall, Waters, Shaw, Carazzo (Ellis, Townsend)
Ablett, Mitchell, Boyd, DalSanto, Priddis, Pendlebury (Sylvia, Williams)
Roughead, Mumford (Stephenson, Campbell)
Franklin, N.Riewoldt, Chapman, Martin, Robinson, Zorko, Fyfe (Maric, Couch)

hespey · August 03, 2012, 05:01:46 PM

ps feel free to comment. i wont bite! :o :o :o :o :o

kilbluff1985 · August 03, 2012, 05:08:22 PM

IMO it is indeed very silly why does it matter about there prices dropping if they are in your finished team?

JROO Has Lions, WB, Dockers, Dons, Port to come an easy run home which is why i got him in my team for the second half of the year should get some decent scores well i hope

your trading in a bloke in Fyfe who's shoulders i would not trust as much as leaving Wayne Carey alone with my missus

You have Mumford who has injury worries i'd be worried about having him in my team with no trades

You picked Lake as a keeper and has done a good job depending what price you paid for him i'd hold on to him

the way this season is gone you will defffo regret wasting these 2 trades for no good reason when one of your players cops a LTI

If your deffo in the final 8 at least wait until next week to do this

jamesalex · August 03, 2012, 05:09:05 PM

Reverse. Need at least 2 trades at the least for finals I reckon.

poolboybob · August 03, 2012, 05:12:42 PM

You're going to suffer injuries and suspensions in finals. Make those trades, but know that you're going to cop some zeroes or (best case scenario) end up playing a bad backup in your starting lineup.

cdonny · August 03, 2012, 05:18:07 PM

Deledio, Scotland, Goddard, Birchall, Waters, Shaw, Carazzo (Ellis, Townsend)
Ablett, Mitchell, Boyd, DalSanto, Priddis, Pendlebury (Sylvia, Williams)
Roughead, Mumford (Stephenson, Campbell)
Franklin, N.Riewoldt, Chapman, Martin, Robinson, Zorko, Fyfe (Maric, Couch)

Team looks relatively solid - where you ranked currently?
Your defence is faultless, if anything, it's too good (ie, some of that star power cash could've being used in your mid/fwd too)
Your midfield is good - though I feel that the addition of a Swan, Selwood, Watson in stead of a Boyd or DalSanto would bump it up in to the elite category.
Rucks worry me a bit - Mumford is in and out all year, and with the Roughead - Bailey, Hale and Buddy all to come back, his scores might suffer due to this?
Fwds - Pretty damn good, the Couch/Sylvia DPP swap saves you the Buddy Donut.

I'd be looking to maybe turn Mummy in to a consistently scoring and playing beast - Jacobs, Goldy, Nic Nat, etc
And maybe one power upgrade in the fwd line, maybe Robinson in to a Beams, or something. Just to solidify your assault in the finals.

That being said, come finals, these POD's might end up turning it on, and win you games - who knows!? That's the beauty of this cruel mistress that is supercoach. Good luck in your matches!

Mat0369 · August 03, 2012, 05:45:42 PM

I would reverse for the fact Mummy has been in and out of the side with injury and you might need the trades on your rucks later (backup is not very reliable in Campbell and Stephenson who are in and out of the team). With only two trades I would not be trading out players who are playing. Also assuming that is Heath Shaw I would keep the trade because he is also very unreliable in terms of his body.

devize · August 03, 2012, 05:54:09 PM

I'd reverse. You have Franklin and Robinson out and they may not even be back next week. Mumford has him injury concerns too. Lake is still playing and can score well (especially after a poor game) and Riewoldt could be on the end of some goals as Richmond have a relatively easy draw and the fact that he's in the race for the Coleman.

You could very well have 3 out for the first week of finals with no trades, so sit tight.