which premo defender for my dad?

[fever]

dad's def atm:

lids, godd, scotland, heater, carrazzo, ellis, broughton (shaw, darley)

5 trades left, 220k bank.

swapping broughton this week to avoid donut. it's an important league game.

[fertalong]

Gotta be the birch if you're looking to make the trade this week.
If you can wait another week, see how waters travels and if he does well this weekend then he would be the number 1 pick.

[Spinking]

I'd normally say Waters, Birch then Grimes, but see Grimes has been named in the guts this week and has been playing much more midfield of late. I'd probably go with him.

[fever]

more votes please!!! gotta leave soon!

[Colliwobblers]

grimes but if you want to play it safe birchall

[Justin Bieber]

So Grimes has one blinder of a game and everyone is back on his train. I would go Birchall, but Grimes is a good POD>

[Colliwobblers]

So Grimes has one blinder of a game and everyone is back on his train. I would go Birchall, but Grimes is a good POD>

Grimes season so far - bold his scores RED the ones i'd be happy with :)

2012 Season so far
Summary    Stats Breakdown
Rd    Opponent    Venue    Score    Avg    Total Score    Price    round price change ($)    round price Change (%)
1    Brisbane    MCG    66    66    66    $329,400    $0    0.00%
2    West Coast    Patersons Stadium    65    65    131    $329,400    $0    0.00%
3    Richmond    MCG    65    65    196    $320,500    -$8,900    -2.78%
5    St Kilda    MCG    111    76    307    $334,200    $13,700    4.10%
6    Geelong    Simonds Stadium    75    76    382    $346,500    $12,300    3.55%
7    Hawthorn    MCG    87    78    469    $363,200    $16,700    4.60%
8    Sydney    SCG    95    80    564    $369,200    $6,000    1.63%
9    Carlton    MCG    90    81    654    $379,400    $10,200    2.69%
10    Essendon    MCG    97    83    751    $390,200    $10,800    2.77%
11    Collingwood    MCG    114    86    865    $405,200    $15,000    3.70%
13    GWS Giants    MCG    89    86    954    $415,900    $10,700    2.57%
14    Brisbane    The Gabba    67    85    1021    $412,500    -$3,400    -0.82%
15    Richmond    MCG    75    84    1096    $393,400    -$19,100    -4.86%
16    Fremantle    Etihad Stadium    105    85    1201    $385,600    -$7,800    -2.02%
17    Port Adelaide    TIO Stadium    135    89    1336    $407,800    $22,200    5.44%

[Spinking]

So Grimes has one blinder of a game and everyone is back on his train. I would go Birchall, but Grimes is a good POD>

Grimes season so far - bold his scores RED the ones i'd be happy with :)

2012 Season so far
Summary    Stats Breakdown
Rd    Opponent    Venue    Score    Avg    Total Score    Price    round price change ($)    round price Change (%)
1    Brisbane    MCG    66    66    66    $329,400    $0    0.00%
2    West Coast    Patersons Stadium    65    65    131    $329,400    $0    0.00%
3    Richmond    MCG    65    65    196    $320,500    -$8,900    -2.78%
5    St Kilda    MCG    111    76    307    $334,200    $13,700    4.10%
6    Geelong    Simonds Stadium    75    76    382    $346,500    $12,300    3.55%
7    Hawthorn    MCG    87    78    469    $363,200    $16,700    4.60%
8    Sydney    SCG    95    80    564    $369,200    $6,000    1.63%
9    Carlton    MCG    90    81    654    $379,400    $10,200    2.69%
10    Essendon    MCG    97    83    751    $390,200    $10,800    2.77%
11    Collingwood    MCG    114    86    865    $405,200    $15,000    3.70%
13    GWS Giants    MCG    89    86    954    $415,900    $10,700    2.57%
14    Brisbane    The Gabba    67    85    1021    $412,500    -$3,400    -0.82%
15    Richmond    MCG    75    84    1096    $393,400    -$19,100    -4.86%
16    Fremantle    Etihad Stadium    105    85    1201    $385,600    -$7,800    -2.02%
17    Port Adelaide    TIO Stadium    135    89    1336    $407,800    $22,200    5.44%

BANG!!!

[Justin Bieber]

Yeah he had a 3 round patch. The 89, 67 and 75 which was disappointing.

I also didn't know he scored a hundred against Freo too haha.

But yeah take out that 135 and I doubt he would be in this poll.

[fever]

went grimes this week due to b/e's, then when ellis tops out he becomes birchall.

thanks for the advice