Giles v Redden who to field?

[tractorfac]

Thinking of goin redden over Giles, good choice?

[Windigo]

Jolly is out for Collinwood.

Could mean Giles might have a better chance to score...But he really has tapered off in recent games.

[Thunderstruck]

tough call, Agree with Windi but would still lean towards him over Redden. Redden presently on extended bench

[HBTD22]

I think you'd have to go Giles, surely a better chance of scoring well compared to Redden?

[Spinking]

I'd go Giles here. Redden to play second fiddle to Lobbe. Good chance to get the vest if he doesn't start well.

[Justin Bieber]

Giles is due for an 80. Biggest spud this guy though ::)

[fertalong]

There is still a chance that Redden can be emg since he's named on extended bench.

Giles is the safer option because of a higher ceiling and Jolly is out.