Baguley Vs Couch Vs Luke Brown

[chadsta112]

Time for me to offload Old Mac. He was great cover for Pendles but with his B/E of 103, I need to cash in. Out of Baguley, Couch and Luke Brown who would you trade in?

6 Trades left with

Ablett, J. Selwood, Pendles, Stanton, Hayes, Gibson, Mcdonald, Sexton

Thinking Mcdonald out for one of the aforementioned 3....then trade in Marc Murphy next week!

[The Bomber]

I think out of the 3 Luke Brown has the worst JS. Baugley's JS has temporarily increased with Hibberd's injury. Couch, I am not sure of anything with him.

1. Baugley
2. Couch
3. Luke Brown

[HappyDEZ]

I agree with The Bomber, def not Luke Brown. With all the soft tissue injuries at Essendon I would lean towards Baguely. The different DPP status of Couch & Baguely could be worth consideration as to which suits your team best.

[quinny88]

People have been saying all year that Couch and Magner play the same role and Magner has that position. No suprises that when Magner was omitted, Couch came in. I cant see Magner staying out of the side for to long though

[Spinking]

I think that Couch is probably the best of the three, but his JS is a mystery. No idea why in a developing team there wouldn't be room for him and Magner. Watch the teams this week and see where they are named.

[The Mighty Hoops]

I think out of the 3 Luke Brown has the worst JS. Baugley's JS has temporarily increased with Hibberd's injury. Couch, I am not sure of anything with him.

1. Baugley
2. Couch
3. Luke Brown

+1

I'll be looking to get Baugley in so I can put BJ back into the backline. I think his JS is better than Brown's.

Assuming you have a fwd-mid link, brown and baugley could provide that fwd-bck flexibility coming to the pointy end of the season. Stating the obvious I know, but it all depends on your team.

[Danstar]

Who ever out of Couch and baguely starts on field will get traded in for me

[dickitch]

Who ever out of Couch and baguely starts on field will get traded in for me

This week?  Baguley is still on his Ps

[cortez]

Yes a  baguley and couch have only played one game but at this point in the season i dont think that matters since we agent getting them in to be cash cows anymore. Personally ill be getting couch in this week due to team structure and the fact that players are at the perfect price to trade in and out to complete my team.

[Colliwobblers]

I think out of the 3 Luke Brown has the worst JS. Baugley's JS has temporarily increased with Hibberd's injury. Couch, I am not sure of anything with him.

1. Baugley
2. Couch
3. Luke Brown

+1

I'll be looking to get Baugley in so I can put BJ back into the backline. I think his JS is better than Brown's.

Assuming you have a fwd-mid link, brown and baugley could provide that fwd-bck flexibility coming to the pointy end of the season. Stating the obvious I know, but it all depends on your team.

I think Couch should have better JS than the other two but depends how long ZAKA is out for ??

i also thought like many that couch should have been playing months ago, so who knows....

[Danstar]

Who ever out of Couch and baguely starts on field will get traded in for me

This week?  Baguley is still on his Ps

Yes, I need to use a trade to get Goddard back into my defence line

[tbagrocks]

Brown will get games, recent injuries to half backs Jaensch and Martin leave a spot for him

[bowyanger]

Who ever out of Couch and baguely starts on field will get traded in for me

I think thats about the best I can do also...the Dons are looking at getting a few back this week or next

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/afl/jason-winderlich-may-return-as-dons-slowly-regain-stars/story-e6frf9io-1226429710773

[chadsta112]

Thought this through and think i'm opting for Baguley. This will give me the mid/def link which will allow me to chuck Deledio, Carrots, Scotland etc. into my midfield which will give me 6 starting premos there.

This will free up some $$$ so I can finally get rid of Malceski for Heath Shaw or the likes and give me a 5 starting premos with Heppell, Grimes, Darley and Baguley as cover. 4 Trades left and one more upgrade to finish my team leaving 2 trades for finals with two hard league games coming up.

Will it work? Lets pray to the fantasy footy gods.

[The Mighty Hoops]

Thought this through and think i'm opting for Baguley. This will give me the mid/def link which will allow me to chuck Deledio, Carrots, Scotland etc. into my midfield which will give me 6 starting premos there.

This will free up some $$$ so I can finally get rid of Malceski for Heath Shaw or the likes and give me a 5 starting premos with Heppell, Grimes, Darley and Baguley as cover. 4 Trades left and one more upgrade to finish my team leaving 2 trades for finals with two hard league games coming up.

+1
Not a bad plan if you need the wins this week. If it's not so important and you can hold out (and I know H.Shaw has a low B/E) hold on the upgrade as you it's been a war field out there and you never know what is around the corner. eg. Buddy losing his license so he may have additional weeks suspension imposed from the leadership group after his injury recovery...who knows!!

All depends on your ladder posi. But as Captain Obvious will point out, two trades with a couple of rounds left before finals isn't ideal.