Plz rate my team... i will give you candy!

Started by X, February 13, 2010, 11:01:58 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

X

PLEASE RATE THIS TEAM!!!

R. Shaw, Gilbee, Mattner, Ellis, Ohailpin, merrett, ladson    blight, carlisle

swan, ablett, montagna, mcveigh, dangerfield, sheldon   strauss, shuey

king, renouf    pyke, lobbe

lockyer, pav zone, brennan, schneider, lecras, mooney, houlihan   bucovaz, tapscott


CHEERS

yogibbear

Fail.

You obviously ran out of money in the forwards and backs and rucks due to Ablett & Swan.

ryza92

terrible....just terrible...clear ur team and start again!

Dees for the Draft

What sort of candy?

Needs work - don't like either of your back rookies.  Strauss probably won't start the season and is more of a SC player anyway (though he could be a good DTer also).  Carlisle is more suited towards SC, and I don't know much about Blight - indicating that there's probably better options out there.

Not convinced about Shaw or Mattner - there are better options, particularly for DT, and I don't like O'Hailpin also. 

Montanga is overpriced, play Danger in the forwards, get rid of McVeigh and Sheldon and bring in some of the quality rookies like Trengove, Morobito, Martin, Jetta, Scully.

Start again with your rucks.  If you want to go cheap, go for Hille and Mumford, but I'd go either one premium, one midpricer or two midpricers (Krezuer, Hille, Mummy etc).  Get in some new ruck rookies also, Lobbe is good, but look at Trengove, Warnock or Skipper ahead of Pyke. 

Get rid of Lockyer, Mooney, Schneider and Houlihan, bring in Davis or Dennis-Lane for Bucovaz.

Basically start again.  It has so many problems it's not worth trying to plug holes.