Upgrading Giles this week to either Jacobs or Roughy thoughts please

[whynot102]

Cant afford Cox and about $2k for the Mullet so leaves me Roughy or Jacobs, was thinking Jacobs however just want peoples thoughts.

[charliesheen]

Jacobs is pretty safe pick.  Hasn't been injured yet.

[masedog333]

yeah im in the same situation but ill probs go jacobs.

i thought originally that hes a chance to get rested but because he is the main ruckman and the inexperienced josh jenkins will have to ruck all day if hes out, he should only miss is hes injured. Jacobs for me

[Sabretooth Tigers]

Roughy by the length of the Flemington Straight. But I'm biased as I have him forward and A Pattison on the ruck bench. Therefore have cover for Goldy and Nicnat. Roughy can kick goals and ruck and with Franklin out for ??? weeks he could score higher than Jacobs. Best of luck whichever way you go. Cheers.