How do i bring in Goodes?

[dallen]

due to a bit of carnage this week i have to look at my trades again. i have 4 trades left and $70k in the bank.


BACKS: delidio, goddard, shaw, waters, birchall, scotland, carrazzo (s.shaw, ellis)

MIDS: ablett, swan, thompson, cotchin, watson, boyd (nicholson, couch)

RUCKS: jacobs, giles (campbell, redden)

FWDS: sidebottom, franklin, dangerfield, johnson, martin, robinson, zorko (smedts, sexton)


I think these are my 2 options - please vote or provide some advice if you think there are better options;

Option A) Trade nicholson for goodes and DON'T trade out waters.
Option B) Trade out waters, shift smedts to backs and bring in Goodes.

[nathan11]

Nicholson has been handy so far for me and will probably continue to be so I would trade out waters as 3-5 weeks is a long chunk of the remaining fantasy season

[Zombie2.5]

If you're going to trade Waters, i think a like-for-like trade would be best. I wouldn't be confident playing Smedts/Ellis or S.Shaw at D7. I think hold waters, he'll be back for finals anyways, then nicholson to Goodes. You'll then have Zorko/Couch/Smedts for your Mid/Fwd cover.

You can go from Nichol straight to Goodes right? If so, looks good.

If not, i reckon skip the Goodes and go Waters to Suckling or whoever.

Good lucK! ;)

[Hagebear]

I would probably go with option A. with only 4 trades remaining id hold Waters, as you have good cover in ellis and shaw for the next few weeks seeing as Goddard will be back next week. Im not 100% sold on Nicholson so bringing in goodes gives ou really strong bench cover in Martin, Zorko etc

[Marcos83]

You dont need him as you have a great team already. Goodes is not necessary just becasue everyone is jumping on.

Hold the trade, 4 is not enough left in my opinion.

[dallen]

yep, talked me out of it... too much carnage going on, can't wait to tune into next weeks mess!