Who gets the chop? Kreuzer or Giles?

[Madmax75]

I am looking at trading either Kreuzer or Giles out this week for Campbell and getting Carrots in which is the trade that a lot of people are doing. This would complete my team at this point and leave me with 5 trades and 135 k in the bank. I am pretty much assured of top 4 in my league being 2 games and % clear from 5th. With the outs this week my opponent has Martin, Buddy and Goddard if they are all out but doesnt have Pendles so this move would help me get some extra points this week too. Decisions...decisions. Help please.

Team:
I know I ran this poll last week but as you cant delete options had no choice but to repost as the options have changed. One idea I heard was to trade Carazzo/Campbell for  J McDonald/Stephenson and then move Goddard to the mids if you have cover and Carrots in D. However with my team that would leave me with 7 premium mids so wouldnt really be ideal unless I can get a F8 (goodes?) at least as it would be a waste having carrots or Goddard on the bench. I would prefer to trade Spurr as hes not playing and Ellis has better JS as a backup but that would mean trading Kreuzer or Giles not Stephenson when id like to have the 3 rucks for security.
I am sitting effectively 3 games clear inside the top 4 in my league have 7 trades left and 110 k in the bank. I also play the bottom 2 teams in my league in the last 5 rounds. So its trade and finish the team now or wait until just before the finals. Havent had so few trades at this time of year in past years so inclined to hold but very tempting to get Carrots this week.

Team:
B Goddard Deledio Waters Broughton Lake Grimes S Shaw (Ellis Spurr )
C Gabj Thompson Watson priddis Selwood McDonald (Pendles Gibson)
R Cox Kreuzer (Giles big o)
F Franklin sidebottom danger Zorko Martin Beams Cloke (couch Dickson)

[Marcos83]

I would hold right there. On top, 3 games clear, bottom 2 left to play, top 4 secure. Can't do better than that. Sit pretty for a bit and trade before finals. Trust me there will be injuries coming and other bargain premiums falling for you to trade into your side.

As you can see what this week what happened to buddy, goddard, boyd?, martin, ect.

[juzztheball]

I'd hold. Ideally, if you had 12 trades or something crazy like that, you'd get rid of them both. Rucks have been a nightmare for most this year, so unless you need some money (id trade giles out before kreuzer, only by a whisker) hold.

[Madmax75]

That was my gut reaction because as you say look at this week and thats before resting etc. Unless someone can convince me otherwise im going to do nothing this week.

[Capper]

it really depends on how happy you are with the rest of your line up.

I mean i have seen people trade Giles and a flowering prem to Campbell and Maric last week.

If you did this you could upgrade Ellis or Darley to anyone and the same with JMAC

[Madmax75]

Yep they are good options but this far out from the finals I think Im not going to trade. If need be ill trade Giles or Kreuzer to Pattison 94k ruck and upgrade closer to the finals. Goodes may be my next upgrade target as my swing f/m. Who would you start out of Kreuzer and Giles?