Redden or Stephenson for Campbell

[david_89]

feel free to justify your answer, thanks in advance!

[T Dog]

Simply who gets you the most cash wins...these 2 just just just..................aaaaaaaaaaaaaghhh... :o

[fever]

dont think either will play again this year. if any of them do, it'll be redden. bigO is done imo.

but i spose redden for the extra cash

[Noz]

Redden won't get much game time with Renouf and Lobbe doing the majority of rucking for us.

[david_89]

yeah thinking redden

[Capper]

i believe Redden is worth more so Redden it is

[roo boys!]

I had the same dilemma, doubt either will play so went with Redden for the extra cash. If, by chance, one of them gets named on Thursday though I'm certainly trading the other.

[Bones Bombers]

Port look to be playing Renouf as preferred ruck and Lobbe score a ton in his first game back so I would think Redden is done for this year.
Big O hasn't gone too well this year but if Geelong don't want to use Hawkins as second ruck at some point then he is a good chance. I don't think Dawson Simpson is any better and Vardy isn't on the radar.
So I will be trading Redden.
Feel free to tell me if I'm wrong!

[Slammer]

Yeah I am in the same boat but only have 6 trades left so I will hold.
I would though choose Redden. With Lobbe back Redden will not play again

[PICCOLLO]

Redden. With lobbe back and renouf still there, he is third choice.