My SC Team!!! Out of 10

[Jezza]

My SC Team:

Defenders:
B.Goddard
C.Enright
S.Fisher
J.Waite
M.Hurley
J.Atkinson
M.Maguire

D.Talia
D.Grimes

Midfielders:
D.Swan
B.Vince
S.Black
A.Cooney
M.McVeigh
R.Palmer

J.Strauss
R.Bastinac

Rucks:
K.Tippett
D.Hille

W.Skipper
J.Fitzpatrick

Forwards:
M.Pavlich
S.Johnson
J.Porplyzia
M.Le Cras
B.Hall
P.Medhurst
J.Butcher

J.Tapscott
T.Taylor

How do you rate the team of out 10 and what changes could I make to improve it.

[lukenmiz]

question marks on waite (knee), hurley (assault charges), atkinson (?).
can black keep on going?
hille's knee?
stevie j - has he started training yet?
hall is good if he behaves
someone like ziebell is probably more worth while than medhurst
i'd look at trying to utilise some of the multi-position players.
6/10 at the moment

[kazam]

team has good potential, just keep eye on players coming back from injuries, some that i have, they should be ok, but just be careful.

Atkinson... make sure he will play before u keep him in best 22. Medhurst i considered coz he coud have a good year, but I would yeh go with Ziebell, just make sure Butcher will also play, i try not to put first year players in my first 22, except martin and trengrove (might trade martin for scully tho)...

6.5/10

[Disco]

agree with lukenmiz on waite, hurley and atkinson (who is he?). johnson and porps not training fully yet. Doubt butcher, Talia, grimes, taylor, strauss will get regular games.

[Gumby]

Too many Essendon players and where is Ablett?

[Jezza]

Here is my team now

Defenders:
B.Goddard
C.Enright
S.Fisher
L.Gilbee
J.Waite
S.O'hailpin
M.Maguire

D.Talia
J.Trengove

Midfielders:
G.Ablett
D.Swan
N.Dal Santo
A.Cooney
S.Burgoyne
D.Martin

J.Strauss
R.Bastianc

Rucks:
K.Tippett
D.Hille

M.Lobbe
J.Fitzpatrick

Forwards:
M.Pavlich
M.Le Cras
C.Knights
R.Murphy
J.Ziebell
C.Mayne
G.Rohan

L.Tapscott
T.Walsh

[Gumby]

Defenders:
B.Goddard
C.Enright
S.Fisher
L.Gilbee
J.Waite (NO)
S.O'hailpin (NO)
M.Maguire (Don't start him)

D.Talia
J.Trengove (Move to ruck and get Sheppard)

Midfielders:
G.Ablett
D.Swan
N.Dal Santo
A.Cooney
S.Burgoyne
D.Martin

J.Strauss (WHO?)
R.Bastianc

Rucks:
K.Tippett
D.Hille

M.Lobbe
J.Fitzpatrick (Replace with Trengrove)

Forwards:
M.Pavlich
M.Le Cras
C.Knights
R.Murphy
J.Ziebell
C.Mayne (NO)
G.Rohan (NO)

L.Tapscott
T.Walsh (NO)