Treolar vs Porps

Started by Shaddy94, June 26, 2012, 05:54:51 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Who should i keep as bench cover

Porps
4 (26.7%)
Treloar
11 (73.3%)

Total Members Voted: 3

Shaddy94

Which one do you think i should keep as fwd cover/ possibly mid cover (Treolar) for my final team, otherone will be upgraded to Robbo.

Treolar higher scoring potential set to drop further in price but is capable of higher scores, lower JS though with resting issues but capable of 80 average IMO

Props Lower scoring potential but good JS and can be relied onto to play each week for a 70

KoopKicka

Id go Porps, remember Sheeds sayng he was only gonna play the rooks about 14 times this season?

Shaddy94

Quote from: KoopKicka on June 26, 2012, 05:56:01 PM
Id go Porps, remember Sheeds sayng he was only gonna play the rooks about 14 times this season?

Yer i know that, but i think Treolar as well as the likes of Shiel, Giles may be the exception of that and maybe will possibly play 15,16,17 games

henry

Keep the cheapest one, upgrade the other. I rate porps probably a bit higher as he will play more games than treloar, and although he won't score the 90s to 100s treloar can he is still more consistent. Treloar burned me with his 21 2 weeks ago so I traded him out last week.

Dudge

Quote from: henry on June 26, 2012, 06:10:39 PM
Keep the cheapest one, upgrade the other. I rate porps probably a bit higher as he will play more games than treloar, and although he won't score the 90s to 100s treloar can he is still more consistent. Treloar burned me with his 21 2 weeks ago so I traded him out last week.

I know where your coming from, as i have him as well, but 1 shocker and  i would of traded most of my team by now. I feel he's reliable bench cover. Ps - i dont have Porps

Windigo

I'd trade out Porplyzia.

Treloar has DPP if you have another link which is handy.