Clifton vs Miles

[Weagle]

Two of the much hyped GWS rookies are getting close to returning, and I'm going to have to pick one up for my bench this week.

So, which should it be and why?

[Ricochet]

why do you have to trade in one of these guys? can't you find cash elsewhere?

[fertalong]

you don't HAVE TO get them as Ricochet pointed out, but if you wanted to choose one, it would have to be Clifton. He's at a higher price, but is mature age, did well in the preseason, and if it wasn't for injury, he was in line for a R1 start. I had him in my team over Devon Smith if named.

[Weagle]

They just seem like better options than any of the mid rooks going around at the moment, nah I can't find the cash anywhere else (to get swan this week).  The only current rook I'm considering is Gibson, but I'm just not convinced...

[Ricochet]

what are your ruck stocks like? considered a downgrade to Campbell?

[Weagle]

Maric, Cox, Redden, Big O. Doesn't make me enough cashola to get swannie

I think it's gotta be clifton like Fertalong said, he was named in GWS's best in their 2's match on the weekend (for whatever that's worth), mature age (25), 89 kg and built like a tank.

Just did a bit more research for those interested...

Round 9 GWS injury update listed Miles & Clifton as both 2 weeks (knee)
Round 13 GWS injury update did not list Clifton (he played), Miles STILL listed as 2 weeks (knee)...

Will be interesting to see if its updated today at all

[TMurphBROWNLOW]

whichever one is picked on thursday night :p (if picked on Thursday night)

[MLS]

Gibson?