Does Shiel have to go?

[The Supercoach]

  :-\

[FonFatty]

Yup, he hasnt got much more to offer $$ wise.
He has also faded away score wise, if you keep him you will lose a substantial amount of coin.

[brownmans muffins]

I'm too undecided to vote. If Carrazzo had bottomed out this week I'd prol go Sheil-Carrazzo.

The dearth of super cheap downgrade options combined with Shiel's position in your team are key.

If he's M6 it's tough to trade him out (you'd need to have a v good M7 ready to step in).

If he's M7 you could probably take that risk - a lot of people including myself would have to weigh up the remaining duration of Pendles' absence.

If he's M8 you've got a sweet midfield and should take the cash by moving to a S.Gibson etc.