Big decision to make...

[Macca#23]

Have the funds to get any defender in my backline if I trade out Hargrave. I currently have Lids, MJ, Birchall, Lake and Hargrave as my best defenders.

So who to get?

Scotland
Waters
Shaw
Adcock
Suckling
Broughton
Heppell
Grimes

Keeping in mind that I don't want to trade Scotland in considering I traded him out prior to round 11, thinking he wasn't going to be back by round 14  >:(

[Jalapeno]

Thats a no brainer mate :)

1. Scotland
2.  Shaw
3. Any of the others

Hope this helps

[phiz3]

Given that you seem to not care about the bye this week ( Scotland and suckling not playing) you should be getting NONE.
Get Carrazo.
Guy smashes it after that long out and was smashing it before he got injured. also underpriced because of his injury affected score still floating around in his 3 weeks.
My opinion, for what it's worth (which is surprisingly little with most :)

1. Carrots
2. Scotland
3. Shaw. (shaw becomes number one if you decide you want to score this week)

[Jalapeno]

Given that you seem to not care about the bye this week ( Scotland and suckling not playing) you should be getting NONE.
Get Carrazo.
Guy smashes it after that long out and was smashing it before he got injured. also underpriced because of his injury affected score still floating around in his 3 weeks.
My opinion, for what it's worth (which is surprisingly little with most :)

1. Carrots
2. Scotland
3. Shaw. (shaw becomes number one if you decide you want to score this
week)

He has actually hit the nail on its head here mate.. Thou really shaw would be the better option due to him scoring this week and prob averaging very similar thru the year....