rate my team please

[dogsss]

hey guys,

this be my pre-season team. thoughts?

backs
goddard, hodge, gilbee, houli, kennelly, ladson , sheppard, davis, trengove

mids
ablett, cooney, carrazzo, masten, trengove, martin, morabito, bastinac

rucks
tippett, kruezer, warnock, charman

forwards
roo, pavlich, harvey, franklin, gray, dangerfield, ziebell, lobbe, gumbleton.

hoping one of gumbleton or lobbe can cover franklin first round.

only $11,100 in the bank left -_-

[JonnyHart]

- If Ladson plays he'll be good.

- Not sure if Morabito is a massive ball-winner, but then that wasn't an issue for Stephen Hill last year.

- Charman is probably not the best player if you want top spend that much on your bench. Hille and Ottens would be better. I like the bamble of Kruezer and Tippett together though.

- Replace Lobbe. Do you really think Gumbleton is one of the two best candidates to cover Buddy? If you do, I commend the size of your balls.

http://thedailydream.wordpress.com

[dogsss]

ic ic thanks for the reply.

i like lobbe in the forward line as i can use him as a mpp with tippett. i can understand your view on charman but his so cheap! haha im not to confident in either ottens or hille.  yeah gumbleton is a worry with his injury problems but if he goes ok in the nab all i want from him is to cover franklin just for the round one. how bout davis instead of gumbleton and maguire in the backs?

[yogibbear]

EDIT: deleted.... was too good.

Instead of telling you what to do i'll say this..

How much upside do you think is in cooney?
How much upside is in franklin?
What happens when your foward rookies aren't playing?

Plus harvey, franklin, dangerfield, ziebell isn't the most reliable 22 game fwd line you could make esp with those rookies.

Nothing wrong with backline really. I like the DP play with carazzo. Should let you cover most gun injuries up back through rotating with midfield rookies to cover injured backmen or vice versa.