POLL - OPINION NEEDED PLEASE !

Started by alex1234, June 19, 2012, 09:15:13 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

who to get in

Joel Selwood
7 (24.1%)
Jobe Watson
4 (13.8%)
Scott Thompson (+little extra cash)
13 (44.8%)
none of the above..
5 (17.2%)

Total Members Voted: 2

alex1234

i want to finalize my team
who it best suited

i have gaj pendles boyd priddis cotchin _________?

david_89

depends on how much money you have and how many more upgrades you need to do?

alex1234

9 trades

this round going upgrade forward and downgrade forward and then upgrade midfield

after that, one more downgrade, one more upgrade (defender upgrade)
^^ the downgrade is a must i think even if i get thompson i dont think il have enough money to upgrade straight up

4 trades to keep for rest of season

EZA100

he is very cheap around 550k and is one of the favourites to win the brownlow a bit cheaper than watson which is good to. your midfield is looking good but to get the best quality player and best brice i reckon thompson besides one bad game of 58 he's range is 90-161.

T Dog


Skullgove

Swan even if you have to use another trade

devize

Has to be Selwood. Hasn't scored under 100 and is still capable of a big score. Scored 104 in a game where he was off the field for long periods due to injury, next lowest score of 112. I'd go Watson next, if you have faith his hammy will hold up.

alex1234

traded in Thompson but I think I may reverse it
I don't really want swan as I already have pendles in midfield and then sidebottom and beams in my forward line
I'm quite keen on Watson but im really not sure, it's so hard to decide  :'(

FonFatty

I am surprised at the NO LOVE for Watson in this poll.

The Bomber

I have a fear about Thompson being rested which is why I haven't brought him in. May be unwarranted but meh.

I'd get Swan. I have Pendles, Shaw, Sidey (and getting Swan), but if they perform then why not have all...

Other than that, Watson and Jelwood seem par. Jelwood is more proven than Watson which accounts for more people choosing him over Watson.

Ringo

Any thoughts or discussion on JP Kennedy from Sydney seeing you do not like Swan.

alex1234

ohh maybe
I still am mainly looking at either of the three above