Quick Poll: Mid Bench Cover

Started by Lozza, June 19, 2012, 07:38:53 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Are Gibson and Williams good enough bench cover?

Yes
10 (71.4%)
No
4 (28.6%)

Total Members Voted: 0

Lozza

Would gibson and williams be good enough bench cover for the rest of year? Obviosuly william's js is not very good and will probably be out of the side when pendles comes back in. At the moment ive got treloar and williams on the bench and am looking at trading in gibson but want some decent cover. Who should i trade for gibson? (if i trade out treloar i will do it this week since hes gonna go down in price)

Justin Bieber

Really not sure on this one.

I'm going to have both of these as my bench as well, so I'm scared as Marly will get dropped soon or even this week and who knows about Gibbo.  :-X :-\

Lozza

Yeah thats what im worried about aswell. Gibson looks to be one of the only decent downgrade options around but if i offload treloar to him i will be relying on him as cover for the rest of the year if williams is dropped

SydneyRox

Gibson should be ok, but williams would have to play better than GAJ to hold his spot

Football Factory

Quote from: SydneyRox on June 19, 2012, 07:55:42 PM
Gibson should be ok, but williams would have to play better than GAJ to hold his spot
+ 1

Windigo

Williams may last a couple more to do a job on the field for the next bye.

Gibbo seemingly has better JS....Same could have been said for Spurr. He has been a no show & Jacob Brennan been playing every week.  ::)

Torpedo10


Hagebear

Having the exact same drama. Prematurely picked up Tom Mitchell early as I needed a downgrade and at the time there was no-one. Now looking at getting gibbo but not entirely sold on his js? Having zorko on my forward bench and not having the dpp link into my mids makes me nervous.

JamSainter

Looking at the way the coach spoke about Gibson
http://www.kangaroos.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/4912/newsid/138748/default.aspx
I reckon he will be around for a while yet.

Lozza

yeah hopefully gibson can hold his spot for the rest of the year and williams can maybe just play a few more games so that if i need to trade him his price would have increased a bit