Cloke?

[Plastic Boy]

He's dirty cheap and can bang out massive scores. 

Was thinking of basically a straight swap for Treloar.

[BBosCo]

ew no. Ive suffered all year with him and trust me hes not worth it.

[S_Coach99]

Collingwood might be willing to pay for the over rated Cloke, but I'm not!

[jaffa35]

That's a bit of a harsh comment - he's a bargain and a straight swap for Treloar is not unreasonable.

[tbagrocks]

form slumps don't last forever, and there is no reason to suggest he won't have a massive second half of the year, he could get close to 100 ave for the last 12 games but there are players getting well over that atm! make sure you have the Beams and Chaps first! then Cloke could be a very, very nice F7

[Plastic Boy]

Fwd line looks like this

Chapman, Franklin, Sidey, O'keefe, Zaharakis, Dusty, Treloar   - Bench - Zorko, Hall

I could swap Zorko into the midfield and Trade in Cloke for Treloar as my 7th Mid.

I will suffer next week though with 5 of those FWDs sharing a rd 12 bye if I bring in Cloke this week, however could swing 1 into the mid bench only making it 4 FWD's missing next week.

[tbagrocks]

Fwd line looks like this

Chapman, Franklin, Sidey, O'keefe, Zaharakis, Dusty, Treloar   - Bench - Zorko, Hall

I could swap Zorko into the midfield and Trade in Cloke for Treloar as my 7th Mid.

I will suffer next week though with 5 of those FWDs sharing a rd 12 bye if I bring in Cloke this week, however could swing 1 into the mid bench only making it 4 FWD's missing next week.

I really think most Coaches will struggle with Fowards next week, with so many of the top liners out! Sydney/Geelong/Collingwood/Essendon/Freo... gee who doesn't have four players there?

[ScottieD]

Agreed, he will provide good bang for your buck as F7.

You

Collingwood might be willing to pay for the over rated Cloke, but I'm not!

Well you wouldn't be: you'd be paying less than a Danny Stanley for example... I think that's a good deal...

[Windigo]

I think he is worth the punt.

Cheap enough, and there is always a chance for a return to form and that return could have started last week.