Porpise v Smith

[Jormas]

in a pickle, both named, both have same scoring capability.

selection cloud over Porpise's head and Smith will be rested due to GWS rotation policy...

WHO TO OUST?

[Perthwildcat]

I had the same dilemma, but with Robbo to trade in.  Looking at the upside, Smith has been pretty good, bar his subbed game.  Porps a KPP and gets less of the ball.  Plus Porps price has peaked.  No brainer.

[upthemaidens]

smith is dpp aswell

[Alka]

It's not a no brainer.

I'd say Porpoise has much greater JS, given he stays clear of injury.
Smith is surely due to be rotated out, which could happen during byes and earn you a donut.

Smith is close to his peak. He might rise by another 30k. I'd rather lose 30k than eat a donut though.

I'm unsure on their JS though, so it kind of depends on that and if people do think Sheeds will rotate Smith out.

[Insider out]

I think porps will be sub this week and bleed cash

[Windigo]

It's a tough choice.

Maybe oust Smith, purely because he is a rookie and could taper off in coming weeks...But is a  difficult one.  :-\