The What to do with H Mac topic

[LF]

Have him warming the bench ATM all that cash sitting there seems a complete waste
My current rucks are Kruezer, Giles,H Mac and Stephenson.
Should I trade out H Mac this week or wait until after/during the byes since I am covered as long as they all play.

[fever]

maric

[brownmans muffins]

I'm in a similar boat (Sandi/Giles/Redden - HMac)
If you trade him out, Maric is looking the goods - bye notwithstanding.

However, Giles has been more than capable (Kreuzer is actually a bigger concern!!) - if you trade HMac out for a premium like Maric you've still got 500K (Giles/Kreuzer?) on your bench - and I'm assuming you'd eventually cull one.

that's a lot of trades to use in the ruck area.

for now, I'm going to hold fire, ride Sandi/Giles as R1/R2 and keep an eye on any playing cheapies in the ruck - the longer HMac is out the better - I don't view him as a premo anymore now that injuries are flaring up and Goldstein has re-established himself in the interim.

[Nyn]

edit; That will teach me for not reading twitter

[Tominator]

mate he won't be back for another 4-6 weeks

[biggy12]

i'm in a similar situation, instead i have the big cox, giles and redden. definitely sick of the cash just lying there on my bench...
i'll be downgrading Hmac to big o, as it suits my bye structure and would like the cash to Beam up Smith!

if you've got playing rucks, which you do, i think it's best to get rid of him not and count your cash. i mean, ruck injuries always seem to be prolonged more than any other position. remember sandy from last year just never got going again!

[bonebones]

so how about a straight swap to goldy and bank the 50k? surely goldy will 100ppg from here on in??

[Tominator]

more replies here if it helps :)

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,60982.0.html#msg786611