Giles to Goldstein? Will cheer for help!

[Jroo]

Now that HMAC is out for 4-6 weeks will Giles to Hmac be a good trade?
Rucks will be Goldstein and Sandi (Orren and Redden)
And will leave me with 14 trades left and only Clarke,Ellis, Horsley, Sloane and Trealor to upgrade?
Will cheer for opinions! THANKS

[remon tea]

Goldstein is a quality ruckman capable of belting out huge scores.

Plus you have a good amount of trades, and the people who you want to upgrade are perfectly capable of scoring good (Sloane, Treloar, Clarke, Horsley).

Do it :)

[Swallow12]

Do it, bit bias but Goldy is a gun! Plus Giles may start to tire as it is his first full season..

[Jroo]

He only averages 85 for the year but with HMAC out can see him dominating and Giles has to go soon anyway. Plus his unique but i am still not sure?

[Bennyy]

Big risk, but risks have shown to pay off.
Just worry when HMac does come back in and then your getting towards finals. Might make you fall at the final hurdle

[remon tea]

Lower average that expected because of poor form at the start of the year.
Plus I doubt he enjoyed or coped with having 2 rucks in the same team.

Yeah he would be unique. I went with Ryder at the start of the year for laughs and it somehow worked :P

[bonebones]

well I am 'upgrading Hmac to Goldy' and saving 50K. Quality ruckman in form, Hmac is gonna struggle and when he comes back I am sure they will ease him back in the FWD role.
I say Giles > Goldy is a good move. Only other option would be wait a few weeks and then go to Mummy.

[ubeaut]

Can u wait a few weeks and upgrade Big O instead? He'll go up by then but so will  Big O. I'd prefer to have Giles all year as cover personally. Giles plays Big O this round so should score well again.

[Dazzalenko]

don't do it, Giles is as good as a premium and has great js, Goldy will be miserable once Hmac gets back

[crabapples]

Yeh im thinkin hmac to goldy. Im sure if goldy dominates once hmac is fit they wont just walk him back into #1 ruck position

[Spuds11]

yeah i agree giles is a keeper and if your other ruck is fine then its just a wasted trade

[Footyrulz]

No! Why would u trade giles if u have in on your field?

That trade might work in 5 weeks

[HappyDEZ]

Personally I would hang on to Giles but it could cost you 15-20 points.

[Samm79]

If/when Hmac comes back, if fully wound up Goldys scoring will suffer again. I like the trade but would be prepared to trade out Goldy when Hmac comes back. I like the trade, Goldie should average 110, like last season in Hmacs absence. Not confident he will though when Hmac comes back. Good luck!

[Noz]

Dont see the reason in wasting a trade Giles should now be considered as a premium don't trade him his still scoring good. Upgrade other areas first then come back to Giles.