My team rate please

Started by Pommy, February 09, 2010, 05:37:04 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Pommy

Backs: Newman, Enright, Hurn, Fisher, Waite, Kennelly, Greenwood (Maguire, Silvagni)

Mids: Ablett, Swan, Cooney, Prismall, Trengrove, Morabito (Shuey, Bastinac)

Rucks: Mumford, Warnock (Lobbe, Skipper)

Fwds: Chappy, ROK, Brown, Porpoise, Rioli, Dangerfield, Watts (Gumbleton, Davis)

50k left. Massive problems in the ruck but hopfully thats where my first upgrade is...

morgs10

i wouldnt have newman, waite (wont play round 1) or greenwood (tagger)
also there are better options than prismall, also i would have dustin martin over morabito should play round one, and morabito had a horrible ave at tac cup level.

forwards chappy for riewoldt no on porps and im a crows fan rioli hasnt had a full preseason. and jack watts is just a silly pick

Big_Cox14

Backs:
Waite is risky (won't play round 1), Greenwood is a tagger, so will probably only score 40-50 pts a game.
Mids:
Pretty solid. But have chosen two rookies as starters. I'd probably swap Morabito for D Martin as Martin should play round 1. I would downgrade possibly Swan for Pendlebury and use the leftover funds to boost your rucks. I also think there are a lot of better options than Prismall.
Rucks:
Don't like the rucks. Both will probably be the second string rucks for their respective clubs. I would definitely upgrade both starting rucks.
Forwards:
I think Watts is a silly pick.

Overall I think that there is some work still needed to setup your side.  I rate your side 5/10.

Sams Town

Morgs and coxy
          Really do you think it matters that much about players that wont play round one? Like Waite,Franklin or Judd (first 3) I mean no offence here, I am thinking out loud but its just vanity really for your rank by total points cause the frey doesnt start till Rd4. Thats just my opinion. Also do you think Watts is just a silly pick? I just need a bencher FWD that will play regularly.
Very good point on Moratibo, I think his scores aside the chances of a richmond midfield needing a rookie more often compared to freeo are slightly better also.
Cheers Mate