The Porp to Cloke, Is it a wasted trade?

[T Dog]

Porps + $28K = Cloke this week. Seems like an upgrade? Looks like a good deal?  :o Any thoughts on whether this may be just a waste of a trade?

[Jukes]

I'm not a fan of bringing in Cloke after what he's done so far this year. Reckon trade Porps to a proper premium when you can afford it.

[Nyn]

Wait till after clokes bye he will be another 40k cheaper. Im doing this.

[Ricochet]

not a fan of having KPP in my dream team ... apart from Buddy of course

[MLS]

123 BE this week. He will bottom out further

[Marcos83]

Porps scores very consistently so he will stay around the same price all year I reckon. Keep him and wait for Cloke to go down even more if you want him but I wouldnt consider him. i'd get on someone else.

[T Dog]

Thanks for the sense there everyone A cheer all round. 8)

[Insider out]

Not such a bad idea but wait until he smashed out a big one.

Last year he went 52,74,48,80 about the same time last year before going 121,117,136, 114