now who to trade to my rucks

[bernie]

so i had mumford got injured and then sellected mcintosh on form now he is injured and need a premium ruck. have giles redden and oren at the moment.
who is the best choice dont want to waste another trade on rucks again with another injury aka sandilands.
who is the best pick up and why?

[Ricochet]

Maric...

1. Killing it
2. hardly any ruck competition at tigers
3. has a mullet

[Artax]

I would play Giles and Orren this week..maybe do a double trade after round 11

[fertalong]

Wait for r12 and get cox. Set and forget.

[bernie]

I would play Giles and Orren this week..maybe do a double trade after round 11

wanna trade this week because that allows me full trades during byes to avoid donuts.

[Alka]

Maric, no competition.

Should play a full season if not injured. Cox will get some rests. Sandi has a niggling injury.

[MickyC]

who are your other rucks? i need to get rid of Hmac too but he's my second ruck with Ryder no1, Giles & Redden on the bench.

I'm thinking there are three good options and one speculator:
(1) Maric (fixes the byes perfectly as you can't trust Reddens JS)
(2) Goldstein (80k less than Maric and who knows when Hmac will be back) + trust Reddens JS
(3) some 85k muppet who will never play and I back Giles for the rest of the year + take an extra donut in the byes.
(4) bugger it and ride it out knowing that he's not losing any value and provides an obvious downgrade if needed.