chapman or stevie j

[goodes37]

chapman or stevie j

[Colliwobblers]

chapman to be safe and he should see more midfield time as the cats cannot win a clearance to save themselves.

Stevie J is a super-gun tho and if the cats are winning clearances he is the #1 fwd in the comp ala 2011.

Chapman got my vote. :)

[Dazzalenko]

Got Chappy about a month ago and has been ultra consistent, Stevie J does have a higher ceiling but is a bit riskier

[HappyDEZ]

tuff call, either or

[yorgis]

chaps more consistent, stevie can get those really high scores but he can have some bad ones

[Lions01]

Steve J big scores were
Round 6 against Melbourne, with no Selwood.
Last week vs the Dogs with No Kelly.

Had big minutes in the mids without both these stars, just wonder if he will play more up forward with both back in the side. He'll still average 100+ but last months average is inflated because of these 2 games.

I would be more inclined to go Chappy as stated hes more consistent   

[Dave085]

Are either of them likely to be rested later in the year???

[fever]

Are either of them likely to be rested later in the year???

depends on how geelong are travelling but it would be reasonable to suspect that they will both miss 1 week at some stage.

[rider]

i picked chappy when both had bottomed out, whilst SJ has pumped some big scores since then not unhappy with reliable chappy (well until he pulls a hammy  :'( )

[elephants]

I have Chappy.

Depends if you want scores of 150 followed by 70 or if you're keener on 110 and 110.