charman hille

Started by sledgey7, February 07, 2010, 06:48:50 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

sledgey7

charman and hille are both so cheap and you know they are good enough to lead the ruck for their teams. i think having one of them in your team is a must but what about 2.
if reports about ess intraclub are true then hille seems to be ready to go and if that's the case it's a no brainer with him only costin $237k.
But what about instead of the usual 2 rookies on the bench you spent an extra $70 to have charman warming the pine and making you money?
would it be a waste even if he jumps in price a lot because you're basically gauranteeing the need to use a trade to benefit from it? what price does one put on a trade?

Trav0

im uncertain if charman gets a game ahead of Luenberger and Clarke, in fact he probably doesnt so the question is will they play all 3?? doubtful.

Hille, not sure how he pulled up from the practice match, although they said he played alright but his knee was swolen and red after the game, so that might mean he wont be ready at round 1 so you will have to wait and see if hes going to play or if they have a better idea on when he might be ready closer to round 1!

FLOPITOUT1


Cruiseon


Have 1 of them is a huge risk, 2 is crazy talk.

BU1101

Charman is a bench option, Hille is a risk - Try Ottens?

Justin Bieber

if clark is moved to the forwards or backs (likely) charman will get the ruck spots with leu.

hille's risky coming off a knee op but has a decent upside as he won't be the only ruck this year (ryder, hooker, laycock  :'( ).

ottens is just like hille. coming off LTI and will play more up forwards (cats might try hawkins in the ruck) and blake should be number 1 ruck.