Todd Goldstein

[KingJB]

Hey guys long time reader first time poster, wondering whether Giles has almost peaked and if it may be worth the punt on a straight swap to Big Goldy who showed his old form on the weekend.

[picker_man]

his scores will be effected again once h-mac is back so to risky and think you should try and find the cash by downgrading a rookie instead. Giles is a keeper ;)

[Windigo]

Safe to say the H-mac & Goldy combo for the Roos isn't working.  :P

[KingJB]

Yeah I think it's a big risk. Too much so, but it was a tempting thought. ::)

[MLS]

Scott was 'on the couch' the other week, and I get the feeling he rates HMac before Goldstien. HMac should be back this week, and Goldy will go back to playing second fiddle.

[Beard]

Giles, as we've all found out, is a brilliant scorer. Unnecessary trade.

[The_Captain]

keep the big fella ! (giles)

[Holz]

Safe to say the H-mac & Goldy combo for the Roos isn't working.  :P

the annoying thing is they are 2 of the best rucks in the comp and teams should have put in a good offer for HMac, i have a feeling he would have been traded if a good offer came in.

Goldy is still a decent pick i would say, wont go 140 with Hmac but should post some good scores.

[Windigo]

Safe to say the H-mac & Goldy combo for the Roos isn't working.  :P

the annoying thing is they are 2 of the best rucks in the comp and teams should have put in a good offer for HMac, i have a feeling he would have been traded if a good offer came in.

Goldy is still a decent pick i would say, wont go 140 with Hmac but should post some good scores.

Always thought Roos were too greedy keeping H-Mac. Could have got some good talent for him and have an elite ruck.

[Holz]

Safe to say the H-mac & Goldy combo for the Roos isn't working.  :P

the annoying thing is they are 2 of the best rucks in the comp and teams should have put in a good offer for HMac, i have a feeling he would have been traded if a good offer came in.

Goldy is still a decent pick i would say, wont go 140 with Hmac but should post some good scores.

Always thought Roos were too greedy keeping H-Mac. Could have got some good talent for him and have an elite ruck.

everonye underated him only roo fans thought he was as god as he is showing.  I had him in the euro and basically gave him away as i had too many rucks and now he is hot property.