R11 Who to Cull?

[owenbond007]

Ok bit bores while waiting for footy to start so I thought Id start a new thread. Looking into the near future who is a keeper of the r11 rookies and who needs culling. Obviously you want to keep the guys who will get a gig r12-r13 and also you want guys that will score well too.

In my backs I got Lake, Waters. - No culling required
Mids I have Boyd, Shiel, & Oldmac.
Rucks No culling required.
Forwards I have Danger, Treloar, Adams, Zorko.

So out of Shiel, Oldmac, Treloar, and Adams 1 or 2 will probably have to be culled.

I rate their JS as:

1. Shiel
2. Treloar
3. Adams
4. Oldmac

Their scoring potential as

1. Oldmac
2. Treloar
3. Adams
3. Shiel

Oldmac will go either next week or the week after. who else should i cull? How do you rank your own r11 guys.

[Chelskiman]

Backs: Hargrave, Bugg

Mids: Boyd, Clay Smith, JMac

Rucks: Cox, Giles, HMac

Forwards: T. Adams, Zorko, A. Kennedy, Dickson

Backs are fine.  I may cop the 0 in the rucks as I have an easy opponent that round, but I'll most likely look to offload one in the middle and one in the forward.  Not sure on who yet.

[LF]

Backs: Hanley,Waters,Bugg
Mids:Redden,Boyd,Old Mac,Treloar
Rucks:Giles
Forwards:Zorko,Dangerfield

Old Mac,Bugg and Treloar are my possible trade outs in the next couple of weeks
But in reality my round 12 bye is worse with 4 forwards out so I may even keep Treloar with his DPP for that round since my only round 12 mid atm is Jelwood.

[picker_man]

backs - hanley
mids - thompson, jmac, zorko
rucks - jacobs, giles
fwds - treloar, adams

Just getting out jmac before his bye, rd12/13 is where im in a lil trouble

[Colliwobblers]

DEF: Hargrave, Darley = No one to cull.

MID: Rockliff, Coniglio, DSmith = Coniglio - Thompson (round 10) + DSmith - SMitchell(SYD) hopefuly (round 11)

RUCK: Giles = No one to cull.

FWD: Dangerfield, Adams, Treloar, Kennedy, Dickson = Kennedy? - TWalsh (round 10) + Treloar - ? (round 11)

Had it all set to miss all but 2 donuts but thinking now the trades are worth more than the donuts they avoid by being used, so I will minimise them but not avoid all of them.

Looking at 4 maybe 5 donuts accross the 3 rounds, the best managed teams can limit it to 2 but I just don't have the trades needed to double trade rooks in and out to achieve only 2.

[Jormas]

All byes:

Backs: Bugg, Clarke/Dempsey, Morris = Bugg probably keep, Dempsey/Clarke -> Adcock, Morris -> Heppel/Shaw

Mids: Jmac, Smith, Horsley = Jmac Keep M8, Smith possible keeper... Horsley -> Thompson/Swan/Stanton/Rockliff rd.12...

Rucks: Giles? = Probably keep unless he hits a wall...

Fwds: Hall, Treloar, Porpise = Porpise -> Beams after byes.... Hall -> Lewis next week; Treloar -> Tommy Walsh next week.

i currently have 16 trades w/ about 5 upgrades to do...

Bench keepers will be:

Dempsey/Clarke; Bugg
JMac; Smith
Redden; Stephenson
Zorko; Walsh

so i should have my last spots as: Back: Hargrave/Bugg Mids: Rockliff/Thomspon Fwds: Lewis/Zaha..

[Artax]

If Sexton goes well he would be worth downgrading a GWS fwd to...has started pretty lousy though, mostly

[ENYGMA]

I have too many Rd 11 players

Backs: Hargrave, Lake, Bugg
Mids: Old Mac, Coniglio, Treloar
Ruck: Cox, Giles
Forwards: Adams, D. Smith

I was thinking Bugg --> Darley in rd 10 (doesn't help the byes but I think Bugg has lost this potential as a keeper and I need the cash)

Lake and Hargrave keep teasing me with their potential keeper statuses. They have both technically 'peaked' if you were looking at them as money makers and not keepers.

Don't know whether to keep Coniglio or upgrade him in rd 10 ... to Pendles

Have to hold the other gws rooks as they still have so much $$ left in them

These byes are so annoying  >:( !

[owenbond007]

I have too many Rd 11 players

Backs: Hargrave, Lake, Bugg
Mids: Old Mac, Coniglio, Treloar
Ruck: Cox, Giles
Forwards: Adams, D. Smith

I was thinking Bugg --> Darley in rd 10 (doesn't help the byes but I think Bugg has lost this potential as a keeper and I need the cash)

Lake and Hargrave keep teasing me with their potential keeper statuses. They have both technically 'peaked' if you were looking at them as money makers and not keepers.

Don't know whether to keep Coniglio or upgrade him in rd 10 ... to Pendles

Have to hold the other gws rooks as they still have so much $$ left in them

These byes are so annoying  >:( !

Id keep cogs if i was you and trade out oldmac. Oldmac has some uestion marks on wether hell be in team in r12 and r13. Cogs should play both after the bye.

[PowerBug]

Ok bit bores while waiting for footy to start so I thought Id start a new thread. Looking into the near future who is a keeper of the r11 rookies and who needs culling. Obviously you want to keep the guys who will get a gig r12-r13 and also you want guys that will score well too.

In my backs I got Lake, Waters. - No culling required
Mids I have Boyd, Shiel, & Oldmac.
Rucks No culling required.
Forwards I have Danger, Treloar, Adams, Zorko.

So out of Shiel, Oldmac, Treloar, and Adams 1 or 2 will probably have to be culled.

I rate their JS as:

1. Shiel
2. Treloar
3. Adams
4. Oldmac

Their scoring potential as

1. Oldmac
2. Treloar
3. Adams
3. Shiel

Oldmac will go either next week or the week after. who else should i cull? How do you rank your own r11 guys.

You also need to take into account who has the most money still to make. ;)