Comments and mark out of 10 please

[lozza63]

This is my latest squad, would like a mark out of 10 please with reasons if possible, thanks heaps!

Goddard, Enright, Fisher, Hodge, Gilbee, Carazzo, Hunt ( Sheppard, Talia)

Ablett, Bartel, Trengove, Martin, Morabito, Cunnington ( Shuey, Bastinac)

Tippett, Kreuzer (Lobbe, Trengrove)

Goodes, Riewoldt, Harvey, Franklin, Cyril, Warren, Moore  (Davis, Tapscott)

There is $46'900 in reserve

Is this list on track or start again!

[ando_10]

not saying start again very very young midfielder you think they will all start the season? martin and morabito will cunnington and trengove maybe not outta 10 ill say 7.5/10

[bjrouse]

not saying start again very very young midfielder you think they will all start the season? martin and morabito will cunnington and trengove maybe not outta 10 ill say 7.5/10

I am

By the time some of those midfield kids are culled then he will need to rearrange the lot

[MiGZ]

Possibly one of poorer teams ive seen. Youll be seeing alot of donuts with that midfield. 5/10. Is this your first year doing SC?

[lozza63]

Okay, overall amateurish and needs work - i get the message now how is this one then? MIGZ no this is my 3rd attempt, i was just canvassing ideas and wanting feedback - this is my  attempt at a more conventional lineup.
Feedback from bj appreciated - went away and thought were would i get the moula for midfield upgrades - sometimes one needs a couple of slaps!

Enright, Fisher, Hodge, Gilbee, Kennelly, Hunt, Davis  (Ladson, Sheppard)

Ablett, Bartel, Mitchell, Swift, Martin, Morabito,  ( Shuey, Bastinac)

Tippett, Kreuzer (Lobbe, Trengrove)

Goodes, Riewoldt, Harvey, Franklin, Dangerfield, Warren, Tapscott  (Davis, Bucovaz)  Bit better than 5-6 out of 10 now i hope!

[vmac66]

team seems set up better ...8...

[bjrouse]

Heaps better. Mids still a little weak
My tip is you have a little bit of cash left, yes??

[Justin Bieber]

nice. a 8/10

backs: ladson on the bench instead of davis? Pretty strong other wise.
mids: will be hoping swift can take the next step.
rucks: good combo
forwards: dont think warren can score well. maybe others at his price. bucovaz i dont think will find game time this year.

[toodledock]

This is my latest squad, would like a mark out of 10 please with reasons if possible, thanks heaps!

Goddard, Enright, Fisher, Hodge, Gilbee, Carazzo, Hunt ( Sheppard, Talia)

Ablett, Bartel, Trengove, Martin, Morabito, Cunnington ( Shuey, Bastinac)

Tippett, Kreuzer (Lobbe, Trengrove)

Goodes, Riewoldt, Harvey, Franklin, Cyril, Warren, Moore  (Davis, Tapscott)

There is $46'900 in reserve

Is this list on track or start again!

-one of the best teams ive seen
-less backs more fwds perhaps?
-9/10

[yeahsup]

with your updated team, it is improved.. but i reckon instead of swift try maybe dalziell or masten both in the 340's.

[lozza63]

: bjrouse
Heaps better. Mids still a little weak
My tip is you have a little bit of cash left, yes??

165k left so yeah a little bit bj - where and who should it go on?

[bjrouse]

: bjrouse
Heaps better. Mids still a little weak
My tip is you have a little bit of cash left, yes??

165k left so yeah a little bit bj - where and who should it go on?

Well if you use Swifts 311,300 and 165,00 you have 476,300
Cooney is only 484,100 and will improve on last year....
So if you can find an extra 7,800 you can get Conney over Swift and about 30-40 ppg more.....
Catch my drift  ;)
Option might be Bartel to Gibbs
I gaurantee you the difference between these two at the end of the season will be far far less then the difference of Cooney to Swift.

Hope that helps

[lozza63]

Okay i'll do that bj  bartel - gibbs & swift - cooney. now how's your team going have u put one out there yet? i'd love the opportunity to see it.
thanks for your input mate!

[verda32]

Love the backline, terrible midfield u can't expect young players to score higher than 50 every week, forward line is solid 6/10