stanton kennady murphy or scott selwood

Started by lordy9, May 10, 2012, 08:12:16 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

which one for my fith mid

stanton
7 (35%)
kennady
2 (10%)
murphy
9 (45%)
s selwood
2 (10%)

Total Members Voted: 1

lordy9


Windigo

Stanton.

Post up the yah midfield.  ;)

fertalong

Stanton has some risk, but pretty huge rewards - See dt scores last week.
However, Murphy for consistency

tbagrocks

as good as the other three are, Mark Murphy was No1 draft pick for a reason, best pick by far!

lordy9

my mid is ablet pendiles j selwood watson horsley j mac grenne sheil

Jukes

Stanton is the highest averaging player this season. Nuff said.

Doyle

Stanton if you want huge scores followed by small scores, Kennedy if you want the 95-120 weekly scores, Murphy if you want an out-right proven gun and Selwood if you want to go unique ;)

Zombie2.5

Murphy is a gun. Consistent scorer and will rarely let you down. He just scored a 94 though so if you wait a few weeks he'll be a bit cheaper.

Murphy for proven gun with great consistency. Stanton for the game-breaker type who loves to kick, inconsistent but his lower scores are still decent, his high are ultra high. Kennedy for quite consistent, getting better and is a Marc Murphy, except not as good (just yet!) plus he can have a high score once in a while. Scott Selwood for breakout gun who is still quite unique but is quite expensive considering how much he's gone up, might slow down though, not the best option but you could do worse.

I say
1. Murphy
2. JP Kennedy
3. Stanton(I just don't like stanton.... or he would be number 2)
4. S.Selwood