dt help

[dockers130]

First Attempt
any suggestions/help??

Backs:
B Goddard, R Hargrave, C Enright, T Kennelly, R Ladson, B Sheppard, P Davis
(B Waters, M Maguire)


Mids:
G Ablett, B, Gibbs, B Vince, R Palmer, J Trengove, D Martin
(T Scully, A Morabito)

Rucks:
M Clark, K Tippett
(R Warnock, M Lobbe)

Forwards:
N Riewoldt, A Didak, R O'Keefe, M Pavlich, J Brennan, L Tapscott, T Dennis-Lane
(A Wonaeamirri, S Gumbleton)
   

not alot of cash left over ($48,200)
whos better sheppard or davis?
and what to do with them?

also not sure on the forwards eg dennis-lane, tapscott, gumbleton, wonaeamirri
any way i could make that any better

[Justin Bieber]

Good start dockers.
i think having 6 rookies starting is not the right way to go in the fact that we don't know how many of them will be playing round 1.

backs: probably upgrade waters and put davis on bench. Backs are really hard to find decent scers.
mids: Like alot. watch for gibbs to get tagged first couple of rounds if there is no judd or murphy. expensive emergencies there. could probably downgrade one of them to free up some more cash if you want.
rucks: solid ruck combo. Not sure if clark will be playing around the ground this year though. CHF?
forwards: real forward loading here. didak will unlikely play centre this year due to ball coming in. probably only start one rookie here imo.

[dockers130]

change it around abit
still alot of rookies though
what do u think
any suggestions

Backs:
B Goddard, R Hargrave, C Enright, S Fisher, R Ladson, B Sheppard, P Davis
(M Maguire, J Trengove)

Mids:
G Ablett, B, Gibbs, B Vince, R Palmer, A Morabito, D Martin
(J Trengove, R Bastinac)

Rucks:
M Clark, K Tippett
(R Warnock, M Lobbe)

Forwards:
N Riewoldt, A Didak, R O'Keefe, M Pavlich, J Brennan, S Gumbleton, T Dennis-Lane
(A Wonaeamirri, L Tapscott)


also who should i get if not didak??
or just keep him?

[GinoGod]

i wouldnt start with 2 rookies in each area

[dockers130]

i know its really risky
but im not a big fan of mid priced players
as rookies are usually capable of similar scores
as long as they stay in the team that is

[GinoGod]

yer but rookies are inconsistent and wont play every game...i fink trengove will play most games...morabito will be in and out....with the others i dont believe they will play more than a handful of games each.
u can keep didak but trade okeefe for rioli/lecras

[Blueboys]

I agree, I wouldn't bank on all them rookies playing, you could come unstuck and have loads of donuts or have to trade your way out. I would go with 1 rookie playing Back/Mid/Forward and 2 on the bench.